The Great George vs Similar Hotels

Rooms are beautifully decorated and well-maintained, offering comfort and style.

Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and beautifully decorated.

Many guests praised the historic character, antiques and interior decoration, but one reviewer called out décor and furnishings as a con, so a slightly reduced score reflects that mixed feedback.

The room was lovely and large, comfortable and clean.

The hotel is quite comfortable and very clean, contributing positively to the overall experience.

Generally clean, but mentioned issues like flickering lights and loud heat pumps.

Consistently praised in multiple reviews — described as 'spotlessly clean' and 'room was immaculate'.

The property was beautiful, our room was comfortable and very clean.

Great location within walking distance to everything, enhancing the overall experience.

Great location for walking to main areas and attractions in Charlottetown.

Multiple mentions of a central, walkable location — 'walking distance to everything' and close to restaurants and sites.

Perfect location for walking to downtown and nearby attractions.

Staff were very friendly and helpful, providing excellent service throughout the stay.

Very friendly staff was mentioned, with helpful reception upon arrival.

Hosts and staff repeatedly described as friendly, kind, welcoming and accommodating (one reviewer named Cynthia specifically).

Owner very accommodating and polite; hosts were amazing.

Excellent breakfast menu with thoughtful offerings that exceeded standard expectations.

Breakfast is included with a wide selection and high quality.

Breakfast repeatedly praised as wonderful, excellent and accommodating (early starts allowed); very strong but scored conservatively to balance overall ratings.

Breakfast was amazing, with great variety and quality.

Amenities including breakfast and happy hour add significant value to the stay.

Good amenities include a breakfast buffet and massage chair in the hallway.

Standard quality for this hotel tier (amenities beyond breakfast and basic B&B offerings were not explicitly mentioned).

Included breakfast was very good with lots of food choices.

Standard quality for this hotel tier, providing good value considering the experience.

High perceived value with luxurious decor and services.

Seen as good value — noted as less expensive than a hotel room while offering a high-quality B&B experience.

A bit expensive for what we encountered, but overall a pleasant experience.