
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
Rotherham, GB
7.6 km (4.7 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rotherham, GB
7.6 km (4.7 mi) from original
Rooms
7.7Room conditions included issues like cracked sink and hanging curtains; refurbishment is needed.
Cleanliness
7.2The room had a mouldy smell, stained lampshades, and the bathrooms showed signs of mold and neglect.
Location
8.3Convenient for events at the Don Valley arena and close to Meadowhall Interchange.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Rotherham, GB
0.77 km (0.48 mi) from original

Rotherham, GB
7.6 km (4.7 mi) from original

Rotherham, GB
7.4 km (4.6 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 6.8 km.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG: 0.77 km (0.48 mi)
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG: 7.6 km (4.7 mi)
Primelodge Rotherham
7.8/10Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
7.3/10Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.4/10The Fitzwilliam Hotel
7.3/10Primelodge Rotherham
7.3Concerns about uncomfortable beds and not well-maintained facilities.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
7.3Rooms were noted to be functional but had issues like cleanliness and maintenance.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
7.7Room conditions included issues like cracked sink and hanging curtains; refurbishment is needed.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
6.5Mixed feedback on room quality; some issues with noise and discomfort.
Primelodge Rotherham
6.4Multiple complaints about dirty rooms and unclean facilities, significant negative sentiment.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
6.4Several guests mentioned that the rooms were either dirty or looking tired.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
7.2The room had a mouldy smell, stained lampshades, and the bathrooms showed signs of mold and neglect.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
6.5Inconsistent cleanliness reported; some rooms felt dirty and run down.
Primelodge Rotherham
8.4Location received mixed feedback; accessibility noted but surrounded by warehouses.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
8.4Location received positive comments for convenience and access.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.3Convenient for events at the Don Valley arena and close to Meadowhall Interchange.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
8.0Good location for access to shopping and venues.
Primelodge Rotherham
9.8Friendly staff noted positively across multiple reviews.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
8.3Staff were often described as friendly and helpful during the stay.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
9.7Staff were warm, welcoming, and responsive to guest needs, providing excellent service throughout the stay.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
8.5Staff were friendly and helpful, providing good service overall.
Primelodge Rotherham
—Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
—Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
—The Fitzwilliam Hotel
—Primelodge Rotherham
6.9Negative sentiment around lack of open restaurant and food quality.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
6.4Food options noted as limited and breakfast quality had mixed feedback.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
9.2Variety of food options and good breakfast; however, drinks were considered expensive.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
7.0Food was good, but service inconsistencies noted; breakfast issues occurred.
Primelodge Rotherham
7.4Basic amenities offered, but some facilities closed for refurbishment.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
6.9Standard amenities were available, with mixed feedback on variety.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.2The hotel offers a range of amenities including pools and gyms, but some were underutilized.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
7.0Basic amenities present, but some were lacking; internet issues reported.
Primelodge Rotherham
8.3Some reviews suggest that the price may not align with quality received.
Garner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
7.8Many guests felt they received good value for the price paid.
Holiday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
8.2Overall decent value, but some guests felt the room quality did not justify the price.
The Fitzwilliam Hotel
7.5Good value considering location and price, but some amenities lacking.
Primelodge Rotherham
Bramley GrangeGarner Hotel Rotherham East by IHG
Bramley ParkHoliday Inn Rotherham Sheffield by IHG
Blue Man's BowerThe Fitzwilliam Hotel
The Aldwarke Acorn