
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.5Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable but some mixed reviews on bed quality.
Cleanliness
8.1Some reports of uncleanliness, particularly regarding dirty laundry.
Location
9.6Great location for exploring the city, frequently mentioned positively.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Radisson Hotel York
8.2/10Middletons
8.6/10Malmaison York
9/10The Milner York
8.2/10Radisson Hotel York
7.7Rooms were noted to be nice but had issues like poor lighting and damaged fixtures.
Middletons
8.0Some reviews mentioned that rooms were small or dated, affecting the score.
Malmaison York
8.5Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable but some mixed reviews on bed quality.
The Milner York
7.9Comments indicate some rooms are small and have issues with lighting and air conditioning.
Radisson Hotel York
7.8Room cleanliness was generally good, but some reviews pointed to dirty or damaged bathroom fixtures.
Middletons
7.8Some reviews mentioned cleaning issues with the rooms, leading to a lower score.
Malmaison York
8.1Some reports of uncleanliness, particularly regarding dirty laundry.
The Milner York
7.9Some reviews mention cleanliness, but also note issues like tired paint and cracked marks.
Radisson Hotel York
9.3Guests appreciated the hotel's great location, close to the station and with a river view.
Middletons
9.1Multiple guests highlighted the excellent location as a strong point.
Malmaison York
9.6Great location for exploring the city, frequently mentioned positively.
The Milner York
9.4The hotel's location was frequently praised for being ideal, especially for New Year celebrations.
Radisson Hotel York
9.3Staff were described as friendly and accommodating, with specific praise for the Paddle Room service.
Middletons
9.2Consistently noted as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Malmaison York
9.6Staff were attentive, polite, and helpful according to multiple reviews.
The Milner York
9.4Guests highlighted the outstanding and accommodating service from the staff.
Radisson Hotel York
—Middletons
—Malmaison York
—The Milner York
—Radisson Hotel York
7.8Breakfast received mixed reviews; some items were enjoyable, but there were complaints about quality.
Middletons
9.0Food quality received high praise from several guests.
Malmaison York
9.6Food quality and breakfast choices were frequently praised.
The Milner York
6.9Breakfast options received poor reviews, especially concerning quality and variety.
Radisson Hotel York
8.3Amenities were generally satisfactory, with good offerings but some issues in service like bar hours.
Middletons
8.5Amenities were generally well-received, though some issues were noted.
Malmaison York
8.6Amenities were generally good but some guests suggested improvements.
The Milner York
7.4Facilities like the spa and pool were noted as unavailable, with breakfast options lacking.
Radisson Hotel York
7.2Some reviews indicated the rooms didn’t meet expectations for value for money.
Middletons
8.5Overall considered fair value for the location and services provided.
Malmaison York
8.5Value perceived as decent but some mentions of high costs.
The Milner York
7.9Mixed feelings about prices versus offered services and quality (e.g., breakfast quality).
Radisson Hotel York
Edwin Ridsdale TateMiddletons
Baile HillMalmaison York
George LeemanThe Milner York
Cholera Burial Ground