
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.5Rooms were generally described as comfortable and well-furnished, with some mentions of minor issues.
Cleanliness
8.1Cleanliness was frequently mentioned positively, with several reviews praising the cleanliness despite noting some minor issues.
Service
9.1Positive remarks about friendly and helpful staff contribute to a strong service score.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
7.5/10The Great Western Hotel
7/10Columba Hotel
8.3/10The Scot
8.5/10Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
7.8Rooms received mixed reviews; some were comfortable but others noted issues such as noise and small size.
The Great Western Hotel
6.0Critiques on room issues such as noise, outdated decor, and lack of hot water suggest poor room quality.
Columba Hotel
8.1The beds were really comfy but a bit dated.
The Scot
8.5Rooms were generally described as comfortable and well-furnished, with some mentions of minor issues.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
6.3There were complaints about the cleanliness, including dirt on the floor and mould in the bathroom.
The Great Western Hotel
5.0Several reviews mention dirtiness and issues like cobwebs and stains, indicating poor cleanliness.
Columba Hotel
8.6The hotel was clean, beautiful inside and out.
The Scot
8.1Cleanliness was frequently mentioned positively, with several reviews praising the cleanliness despite noting some minor issues.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
8.3The location is frequently praised as a positive aspect of the hotel.
The Great Western Hotel
10.0Multiple mentions of a good location, particularly in regards to exploring Oban.
Columba Hotel
8.8Fabulous location! Couldn't get closer to the bay.
The Scot
9.1Many reviews highlighted the excellent location, central to attractions and conveniences.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
8.8Many reviews highlight the excellent service and friendly staff.
The Great Western Hotel
8.0Mixed reviews on service; some staff were accommodating, but complaints about the manager's attitude were prominent.
Columba Hotel
8.7The staff couldn't do enough to help you.
The Scot
9.1Positive remarks about friendly and helpful staff contribute to a strong service score.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
—The Great Western Hotel
—Columba Hotel
—The Scot
—Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
5.8There were significant complaints about the quality of food served at the hotel.
The Great Western Hotel
7.0Breakfast received mixed feedback with specific complaints about food temperature and quality.
Columba Hotel
7.5Food was not great at the onsite restaurant.
The Scot
8.1Breakfast received positive feedback, but the lack of an open restaurant during dinner hours was a downside.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
7.3Amenities were mentioned as generally satisfactory but lacking in some areas like lighting.
The Great Western Hotel
6.0Reviews highlight insufficient amenities such as no hot water and a malfunctioning lift.
Columba Hotel
8.3Amenities were fab; the lift was a bit tricky.
The Scot
8.1Amenities like breakfast and parking were mentioned positively, though some reviewers noted missing features.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
7.8Guests found good value for the price, though food quality was questioned.
The Great Western Hotel
7.0Guests feel the hotel does not deliver value given the poor conditions and higher charges for parking.
Columba Hotel
8.1Good value for money, with some overpriced food options.
The Scot
8.5Good value was mentioned, particularly in relation to location and service, which justifies a solid rating.
Muthu Oban Regent Hotel
War MemorialThe Great Western Hotel
Oban 51st Highland Division War MemorialColumba Hotel
War MemorialThe Scot
War Memorial