
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Most rooms are described as comfortable, though some comments about small bathrooms exist.
Cleanliness
9.4Reviews consistently describe the accommodation as pristine and spotlessly clean.
Location
9.4The location is mentioned positively, being within walking distance to amenities.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Carnson House
8.5/10The Stanley
8.2/10The Longboat Inn
8.2/10Bay Lodge
9.5/10Carnson House
7.9Some rooms described as small or cramped but overall comfortable.
The Stanley
8.4Rooms were clean and comfortable, although some were noted to be small.
The Longboat Inn
7.0Thin walls, dated rooms, and several issues reported.
Bay Lodge
8.8Most rooms are described as comfortable, though some comments about small bathrooms exist.
Carnson House
8.0Generally clean but some guests mentioned noise and small issues in bathrooms leading to a lower score.
The Stanley
7.9Some reviews mention clean rooms, but issues like crumbs and hairs indicate room for improvement.
The Longboat Inn
7.5Rooms very dated and not very clean.
Bay Lodge
9.4Reviews consistently describe the accommodation as pristine and spotlessly clean.
Carnson House
9.0Great location near transport links, highly appreciated by guests.
The Stanley
9.4Consistently praised for its great location near ferry and town.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Location is perfect, right across from railway station.
Bay Lodge
9.4The location is mentioned positively, being within walking distance to amenities.
Carnson House
8.9Friendly and helpful staff, consistently praised by guests.
The Stanley
9.4Staff described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Staff excellent and helpful, very pleasant and accommodating.
Bay Lodge
9.9Clare and the staff are repeatedly praised for their hospitality and helpfulness.
Carnson House
—The Stanley
—The Longboat Inn
—Bay Lodge
—Carnson House
9.0Breakfast frequently mentioned as good quality and enjoyable by guests.
The Stanley
5.4No food options available at the hotel, and breakfast service is no longer provided.
The Longboat Inn
8.9Food is absolutely amazing for breakfast and dinner.
Bay Lodge
9.9Guests rave about the quality and variety of breakfasts served.
Carnson House
8.4Basic amenities present; some guests expressed a desire for more options.
The Stanley
7.9No breakfast service and limited amenities mentioned.
The Longboat Inn
8.0Good food option downstairs and friendly staff.
Bay Lodge
9.4Free parking and convenient access to the surrounding area are noted.
Carnson House
8.4Good value attributed to competitive pricing and included breakfast.
The Stanley
8.4Room rates considered high for what's offered, particularly in regard to breakfast.
The Longboat Inn
8.0Generally good value, but some felt not reflecting the room rate.
Bay Lodge
9.3Guests feel they received excellent value, especially considering the complimentary breakfast.
Carnson House
Humphry DavyThe Stanley
St Anthony's GardensThe Longboat Inn
Humphry DavyBay Lodge
Princess May recreation ground