Our pick
Thatched Cottage Hotel
Brockenhurst, GB
★ 0-star8.9/10974 reviews
0.26 km (0.16 mi) from original
English
Cottage Lodge Hotel vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
9.2Rooms nice and clean, very sweet with good tea and coffee facilities.
Location
9.2Great location with nearby pubs and a charming village atmosphere.
Service
9.3Amazing hosts and friendly staff, accommodating to special requests.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Thatched Cottage Hotel
Brockenhurst, GB
★ 0-star8.9/10974 reviews
0.26 km (0.16 mi) from original
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
Brockenhurst, GB
★ 4-star8.9/102,261 reviews
0.77 km (0.48 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Cottage Lodge Hotel
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms8.9
The Filly Inn
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms8.7
Amenities & Facilities8.8
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms8.7
Amenities & Facilities8.7
Key differences
Rooms
Cottage Lodge Hotel8.9
Thatched Cottage Hotel8.1
Cleanliness
Thatched Cottage Hotel9.2
The Filly Inn7.8
Service
Cottage Lodge Hotel9.8
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group9.2
Food & Breakfast
Cottage Lodge Hotel9.5
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group8.7
Amenities & Facilities
The Filly Inn8.8
Thatched Cottage Hotel8.1
Value
Cottage Lodge Hotel9.4
The Filly Inn8.2
Cottage Lodge Hotel amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceConcierge serviceLift / ElevatorWheelchair accessible
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.7 km.
Thatched Cottage Hotel: 0.26 km (0.16 mi)
The Filly Inn: 1.9 km (1.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.2/10Thatched Cottage Hotel
8.9/10The Filly Inn
8.7/10Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.9/10Rooms
Cottage Lodge Hotel
8.9Great room and comfortable
Thatched Cottage Hotel
8.1Spacious yet quaint rooms, although some mentioned steep stairs.
The Filly Inn
8.7Rooms were generally described as comfortable and well-decorated, with some concerns regarding odors.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.7Rooms are spacious and beautifully decorated.
Cleanliness
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.1Room spotless, very comfortable
Thatched Cottage Hotel
9.2Rooms nice and clean, very sweet with good tea and coffee facilities.
The Filly Inn
7.8Several reviews mentioned issues with unpleasant odors and dust, indicating lower cleanliness.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier
Location
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.3Stunning location, ideal location in the village
Thatched Cottage Hotel
9.2Great location with nearby pubs and a charming village atmosphere.
The Filly Inn
9.3The location received high marks for convenience to nearby attractions and transport.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
9.3Superb location with access to beautiful landscapes and the village nearby.
Service
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.8Hosts were very friendly and welcoming
Thatched Cottage Hotel
9.3Amazing hosts and friendly staff, accommodating to special requests.
The Filly Inn
9.3Many reviews praised the staff's friendliness and helpfulness, highlighting excellent service.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
9.2Staff are warm and welcoming, with excellent customer service.
Sleep & Noise
Cottage Lodge Hotel
—Thatched Cottage Hotel
—The Filly Inn
—Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
—Food & Breakfast
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.5Breakfast excellent, staff and breakfast amazing
Thatched Cottage Hotel
9.2Breakfast was lovely and good value, with great tea service.
The Filly Inn
8.8Food quality received positive comments, although there were mentions of inconsistency.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.7Breakfast with a range of options; overall excellent food quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Cottage Lodge Hotel
8.3Access to accommodation and lack of EV charging points.
Thatched Cottage Hotel
8.1Good parking and lovely tea room, but some facilities showed signs of wear.
The Filly Inn
8.8Amenities were noted to be good, with specific mentions of helpful items like a fridge.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.7Good amenities including a Dyson hairdryer and a kettle.
Value
Cottage Lodge Hotel
9.4Pleasant stay and great value
Thatched Cottage Hotel
9.1Great value for a lovely stay, breakfast included and excellent quality.
The Filly Inn
8.2Some reviews mentioned feeling it was overpriced for the offered amenities, affecting perceived value.
Forest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
8.7Hotel offers great value for the quality provided.
Landmarks
Cottage Lodge Hotel
Brockenhurst ManorThatched Cottage Hotel
Brockenhurst ManorThe Filly Inn
Brockenhurst ManorForest Park Country Hotel & Inn, Brockenhurst, New Forest, Hampshire - The Coaching Inn Group
Brockenhurst Manor