
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
10.0Guests often mention the comfort and quality of the rooms, particularly in the cave-style accommodations.
Cleanliness
10.0Most reviews highlight cleanliness positively, with guests mentioning comfortable and clean rooms.
Location
10.0The location is frequently mentioned as a highlight, with guests appreciating its convenience and views.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Caveoso Hotel
8.6/10Hotel San Giorgio
9.4/10PIANELLE RESORT
9.6/10Il Belvedere
10/10Caveoso Hotel
7.0Unique and beautiful cave-style rooms praised for character and space, but several guests reported issues: outdated bathrooms, lamps not working, falling ceiling pieces in one report, and some beds less comfortable.
Hotel San Giorgio
9.5The unique cave room experience and overall comfort were positively highlighted.
PIANELLE RESORT
9.7Fantastic rooms, with unique features and well-furnished.
Il Belvedere
10.0Guests often mention the comfort and quality of the rooms, particularly in the cave-style accommodations.
Caveoso Hotel
8.6Generally clean rooms noted by multiple guests (e.g., 'tuba oli puhas'); no widespread cleanliness complaints though cave rooms can show natural wear.
Hotel San Giorgio
8.6One review noted that cleanliness was not 100%.
PIANELLE RESORT
9.5Mentioned as very clean and beautifully decorated.
Il Belvedere
10.0Most reviews highlight cleanliness positively, with guests mentioning comfortable and clean rooms.
Caveoso Hotel
9.4Excellent central location in the Sassi/old town repeatedly praised ('in the heart of Matera', 'Super Lage'), though access by car/parking is limited and can require a short walk.
Hotel San Giorgio
10.0Multiple reviews praised the central and convenient location.
PIANELLE RESORT
10.0The hotel is centrally located with easy access to attractions.
Il Belvedere
10.0The location is frequently mentioned as a highlight, with guests appreciating its convenience and views.
Caveoso Hotel
8.9Staff repeatedly described as very helpful and kind, providing local tips and good reception service, with a few mentions that reception could be friendlier in individual cases.
Hotel San Giorgio
10.0Staff were described as helpful and friendly in multiple reviews.
PIANELLE RESORT
10.0Staff was extremely helpful and friendly across multiple reviews.
Il Belvedere
10.0Numerous reviews praise the staff for being friendly and helpful, suggesting excellent service.
Caveoso Hotel
—Hotel San Giorgio
—PIANELLE RESORT
—Il Belvedere
—Caveoso Hotel
8.8Breakfast frequently praised as fantastic (good quality, option to have in room), with occasional notes about limited hot items and pre-selection required on some stays.
Hotel San Giorgio
9.0Breakfast supplies were well received, though some items were noted as lacking.
PIANELLE RESORT
9.0Breakfast was praised, but some reviews noted it could be improved.
Il Belvedere
10.0Several guests enjoyed the breakfast offerings, indicating satisfaction with food quality.
Caveoso Hotel
8.3Basic amenities are available (breakfast served in-room or common area without extra charge, motorbike parking nearby), but no kitchen and limited parking; some bathroom fittings (shower pressure) were criticized.
Hotel San Giorgio
9.1Good breakfast and room service were mentioned but some amenities were missing.
PIANELLE RESORT
9.3Good amenities mentioned with emphasis on the unique cave room.
Il Belvedere
10.0Some reviews mention amenities like breakfast, though specific details are less frequently provided.
Caveoso Hotel
8.9Multiple guests mention the hotel as an excellent or good value for a unique experience in Matera; praised for décor and overall offering relative to price.
Hotel San Giorgio
9.5Overall value is perceived positively given the unique experience.
PIANELLE RESORT
9.4Excellent value given the quality of service and amenities.
Il Belvedere
10.0Positive remarks suggest that guests felt their stay offered good value, especially considering location and quality.
Caveoso Hotel
La MatronaHotel San Giorgio
Sant Pietro BarisanoPIANELLE RESORT
La MatronaIl Belvedere
Convicino Sant'Antonio