
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.4Rooms were spacious and comfortable, though some rooms felt tired.
Cleanliness
8.0The property was clean and warm, but there were concerns about the lack of an immediate resolution for lost items.
Location
9.0Excellent location, great for visiting local attractions.


St Austell, GB
0.60 km (0.37 mi) from original


St Austell, GB
4.1 km (2.6 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 3.5 km.
Porth Avallen Hotel: 0.60 km (0.37 mi)
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges: 4.1 km (2.6 mi)
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9/10Porth Avallen Hotel
7.8/10Rashleigh Arms
8.5/10The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.5/10The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
8.2Some dissatisfaction with small room size and bad view for certain guests.
Porth Avallen Hotel
7.5Rooms were described as clean and comfortable, though a few guests found them standard.
Rashleigh Arms
8.4Rooms were spacious and comfortable, though some rooms felt tired.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Rooms were generally well-received, though issues with room configuration were noted.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
8.2One review mentioned a dirty roof and standing water from the room.
Porth Avallen Hotel
7.5Clean rooms were mentioned, but some guests found issues related to cleanliness in common areas.
Rashleigh Arms
8.0The property was clean and warm, but there were concerns about the lack of an immediate resolution for lost items.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
7.8Several comments noted dirty cutlery and crockery, affecting the overall impression of cleanliness.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Beautiful views and great location mentioned in several reviews.
Porth Avallen Hotel
8.5Multiple reviews highlighted the fantastic location near the beach.
Rashleigh Arms
9.0Excellent location, great for visiting local attractions.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8No issues mentioned; positive sentiment about location inferred from overall positive reviews.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.7Exceptional service praised throughout multiple reviews.
Porth Avallen Hotel
8.0Staff were frequently praised for friendliness and helpfulness.
Rashleigh Arms
8.9Staff were praised as polite, helpful, and friendly throughout the stay.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8The staff were described as friendly and attentive, with some exceptions noted in isolated experiences.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
—Porth Avallen Hotel
—Rashleigh Arms
—The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
—The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Food highly praised for quality and variety.
Porth Avallen Hotel
7.5Food quality received mixed reviews; particularly noted was the limited variety due to off-peak season.
Rashleigh Arms
8.5Breakfast and meals were highlighted as delicious and good quality.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Overall good feedback on food quality; however, issues with service during meal times affected perception.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Great amenities like pool, spa, and vegan breakfast mentioned positively.
Porth Avallen Hotel
7.0Some amenities had issues such as limited breakfast options and low shower pressure.
Rashleigh Arms
8.4Amenities were well-received, including good toiletries and a coffee machine.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Facilities like the spa were appreciated, though some comments indicated potential for improvement.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Overall experience suggests the quality justifies the price.
Porth Avallen Hotel
8.0Guests felt it was good value compared to other options in the area.
Rashleigh Arms
8.4Good value for money based on comfort and services provided.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8Guests felt value was acceptable given the general positives, though some questioned specifics.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
KidzworldPorth Avallen Hotel
Old MineRashleigh Arms
Old MineThe Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
Polgooth Mine