Earnslaw Lodge vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were clean and comfortable, though beds could be improved.

Rooms were mentioned as spacious and comfortable with excellent views.

Rooms were described as spacious and well-equipped, but some noted needed repairs.

Rooms are generally comfortable but some furnishings are dated and there are issues like traffic noise and small room sizes.

Some comments about a shabby bathroom and dated decor.

Cleanliness was generally praised, with mentions of well-maintained rooms.

Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, including unclean bathrooms and towels.

Multiple reports of rooms not being clean and issues with the bathroom. Cleanliness needs improvement.

Great location with beautiful views and walking distance to shops.

The location was noted as perfect, with easy access to the city and beautiful views.

Consistently praised for its proximity to attractions and amazing views.

Location is frequently mentioned as a strong point, with easy access to attractions.

Staff were friendly and helpful throughout the stay.

The staff were described as friendly and accommodating, contributing positively to the experience.

Many reviews highlighted the friendly and helpful staff.

Staff received positive mentions for being lovely and accommodating, although reception service needed improvement.

No food onsite; some may want more dining options.

No specific mentions, but the kitchenette allowed for self-catering.

Food quality was generally praised, though some mentioned the absence of dining options.

No specific mentions; general expectation for a hotel of this tier.

Some facilities are dated and could benefit from updates.

Amenities like a kitchenette and heated bathroom floors were well-received.

Limited amenities reported, with mixed reviews about the condition.

Amenities like the sauna and spa bath are well-received, but some issues were noted like parking and laundry facilities.

Generally considered good value for the views and location.

Some reviews suggested that the value did not match the high prices.

Complaints about lack of cleanliness and high prices suggest poor value.

Some guests find it overpriced compared to the service and cleanliness.