
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.7Rooms were clean and adequately furnished, though some bedrooms were small.
Cleanliness
9.3The house was absolutely spotless and well cared for.
Location
9.8Excellent central location with lovely views of the river.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Gisborne, NZ
0.41 km (0.25 mi) from original


Gisborne, NZ
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original
Emerald Hotel
7.4/10Portside Hotel Gisborne
8.5/10Esplanade Townhouse
9.2/10Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.6/10Emerald Hotel
7.3Rooms varied in quality; some were nice while others were described as underwhelming and outdated.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
8.6Rooms were clean and comfortable, although some mentioned issues with the air conditioning and shower.
Esplanade Townhouse
8.7Rooms were clean and adequately furnished, though some bedrooms were small.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.3Rooms are spacious and comfortable, but some complaints about noise and room features affect the rating.
Emerald Hotel
5.8Multiple reviews indicate issues with cleanliness, including dirty rooms and poor maintenance.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
8.1Rooms were comfortable and the standard of hygiene is outstanding, but some reviews indicated minor issues with amenities like the shower.
Esplanade Townhouse
9.3The house was absolutely spotless and well cared for.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.6Overall sentiment indicates cleanliness with mentions of clean rooms.
Emerald Hotel
9.3Positive sentiments regarding the hotel's location near bars and restaurants.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
9.2Close proximity to town and great access to the beach and port, providing guests with excellent convenience.
Esplanade Townhouse
9.8Excellent central location with lovely views of the river.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
9.0Great location near the beach and central amenities as mentioned in multiple reviews.
Emerald Hotel
8.3Service mentioned as standard but some complaints about unresponsive reception.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
9.1Staff were amazing and provided exceptional service, being genuine and friendly throughout the stay.
Esplanade Townhouse
9.8Owners were welcoming and responsive, providing personal care and kindness.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
9.1Reviews indicate very welcoming and friendly staff, showing high satisfaction with service.
Emerald Hotel
—Portside Hotel Gisborne
—Esplanade Townhouse
—Captain Cook Motor Lodge
—Emerald Hotel
7.8No specific feedback on food options; breakfast not available.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
8.1No specific food and beverage reviews indicated; standard quality for this hotel tier.
Esplanade Townhouse
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.2Noteworthy Korean food mentioned, but overall food-related comments are minimal.
Emerald Hotel
6.8Limited amenities noted, including no breakfast options and poor facilities.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
7.6Basic fitness center noted as a downside; some wished for more amenities such as an in-house cafe or bar.
Esplanade Townhouse
8.8Well equipped with nice amenities for a comfortable stay.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.4Adequate amenities provided, but some guests found limited entertainment options.
Emerald Hotel
5.7Many reviews expressed that the hotel was overpriced for the quality received.
Portside Hotel Gisborne
8.6Great value for money based on room quality and location despite some minor complaints.
Esplanade Townhouse
9.2Good value considering the location and quality of the property.
Captain Cook Motor Lodge
8.5Generally perceived as good value, but some guests noted a lack of value in specific aspects.
Emerald Hotel
Endeavour ParkPortside Hotel Gisborne
Te Wai o HiharoreEsplanade Townhouse
New Zealand Frog muralCaptain Cook Motor Lodge
Railway Station Reserve