
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.4Rooms were comfortable but had some mentions of being dated and noisy.
Cleanliness
8.4Several reviews highlighted cleanliness positively, but there were comments about dated facilities.
Location
9.4Multiple mentions of convenient location near the city center.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




The compared hotels differ by 1.0 km.
Sahara Guest House: 0.51 km (0.32 mi)
Chalet Backpackers: 1.6 km (0.96 mi)
The Stables Dunedin
8.8/10Sahara Guest House
9.1/10UpTown Backpackers
8/10Chalet Backpackers
7.7/10The Stables Dunedin
8.7Rooms generally comfortable but some noted size issues and minor maintenance concerns.
Sahara Guest House
8.4Rooms were comfortable but had some mentions of being dated and noisy.
UpTown Backpackers
7.5Described as small and cramped in some reviews, impacting overall comfort.
Chalet Backpackers
6.5Concern about rooms needing upgrades and issues with comfort and ventilation.
The Stables Dunedin
8.4Some concern with cleanliness noted, particularly cobwebs and issues reported.
Sahara Guest House
8.4Several reviews highlighted cleanliness positively, but there were comments about dated facilities.
UpTown Backpackers
7.1Multiple reviewers noted issues with bathroom cleanliness and water accumulation.
Chalet Backpackers
6.5Mentioned issues with cleanliness in multiple reviews, such as dirty kitchens and poorly maintained facilities.
The Stables Dunedin
9.0Multiple reviews praise the location for its proximity to downtown and cafes.
Sahara Guest House
9.4Multiple mentions of convenient location near the city center.
UpTown Backpackers
9.1Consistently highlighted as a great feature, central to attractions and transport.
Chalet Backpackers
8.6Positive comments about the location being central and convenient for various needs.
The Stables Dunedin
9.2Several reviews highlight helpful property management and friendly staff.
Sahara Guest House
9.9Most reviews praised the staff's friendliness and hospitality.
UpTown Backpackers
8.6Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
Chalet Backpackers
8.6Generally positive feedback on friendly staff and responsive service, though some mentioned busy periods.
The Stables Dunedin
—Sahara Guest House
—UpTown Backpackers
—Chalet Backpackers
—The Stables Dunedin
8.2Not specifically mentioned, assumed standard for this type of accommodation.
Sahara Guest House
8.9Breakfast received generally good reviews, though some found it limited.
UpTown Backpackers
8.1No specific feedback on food; assumed standard quality for a hostel.
Chalet Backpackers
7.5Not explicitly mentioned, but basic kitchen facilities noted positively.
The Stables Dunedin
8.8Good amenities available, although a microwave was missed by some guests.
Sahara Guest House
8.9Positive feedback on parking and common areas, but noted limited breakfast options.
UpTown Backpackers
7.1Basic amenities and some communal areas noted as inadequate.
Chalet Backpackers
7.5Amenities were found satisfactory, although some noted that facilities could be inadequate at times.
The Stables Dunedin
9.0Reports of good value for the quality of the stay.
Sahara Guest House
9.4Several reviews highlighted good value for the price.
UpTown Backpackers
8.5Affordable rates were frequently praised while maintaining a decent quality.
Chalet Backpackers
8.6Good value for the price, especially in relation to location and room conditions.
The Stables Dunedin
Dunedin Peace PoleSahara Guest House
Musem ReserveUpTown Backpackers
Street Art TrailChalet Backpackers
No 18