Our pick
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9/10262 reviews
1.7 km (1.0 mi) from original
English
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.7Most comments speak to the good quality, though one mention of extremely uncomfortable beds.
Cleanliness
8.2Overall positive with some complaints about dirty/stained bedding.
Location
9.2Many reviews highlight the excellent and convenient location.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
Pretoria, ZA
★ 3-star7.9/10729 reviews
0.91 km (0.57 mi) from original
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
Pretoria, ZA
★ 3-star7.3/101,031 reviews
1.3 km (0.79 mi) from original
Our pick
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9/10262 reviews
1.7 km (1.0 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony8.7
The Wild Peach - Menlyn7.1
Cleanliness
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony8.2
The Wild Peach - Menlyn6.1
Location
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony9.2
The Wild Peach - Menlyn8.6
Service
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony9.7
The Wild Peach - Menlyn7.6
Food & Breakfast
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony8.7
The Wild Peach - Menlyn6.6
Amenities & Facilities
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony9.2
The Wild Peach - Menlyn7.1
Value
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony9.2
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse7.2
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay amenity advantages
Fitness center24-hour front deskLift / Elevator
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse amenity advantages
Business centerWheelchair accessibleFamily roomsSun loungers or beach chairs
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony amenity advantages
Air conditioningPets allowed
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.76 km.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse: 0.91 km (0.57 mi)
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony: 1.7 km (1.0 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
8/10TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.9/10The Wild Peach - Menlyn
7.3/10Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
9/10Rooms
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
7.4Variable room quality with some clean and spacious rooms, but also issues raised about noise and maintenance.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.7Mixed reviews regarding room quality; several concerns about noise and maintenance.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
7.1Reviews were mixed, with mentions of creaky beds and issues with room amenities.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
8.7Most comments speak to the good quality, though one mention of extremely uncomfortable beds.
Cleanliness
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
7.0Issues with cleanliness in several reviews, including complaints about dirty rooms and cockroaches.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.2Some reviews mentioned leaking sinks and overall cleanliness issues.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
6.1Several reviews highlighted issues with cleanliness, including complaints about spider webs and cold showers.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
8.2Overall positive with some complaints about dirty/stained bedding.
Location
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
9.0Many guests appreciated the convenient location close to shops and amenities.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
8.7A number of reviews praised the great location of the hotel.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
8.6Various reviews praised the top-tier location.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
9.2Many reviews highlight the excellent and convenient location.
Service
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
8.4Most reviews mention friendly staff; however, there were some complaints about unhelpful responses.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
8.2Most guests found staff to be helpful and friendly, though there were a couple of negative mentions.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
7.6Mixed sentiments overall, with some positive comments about helpful staff but negative experiences related to check-out.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
9.7Great service overall, though there were booking confusion issues.
Sleep & Noise
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
—TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
—The Wild Peach - Menlyn
—Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
—Food & Breakfast
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
8.0Not specifically mentioned in reviews; assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.7Breakfast options were mentioned as limited but satisfactory.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
6.6Breakfast was noted as good but repetitive and lacking variety.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
8.7No specific comments, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
8.4Facilities like the gym and lounge were positively noted, although some guests experienced noise disturbances.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.7Some amenities mentioned were lacking, but others were satisfactory.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
7.1The hotel provided basic amenities, but some guests noted shortages or malfunctions.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
9.2Positive sentiment about the equipped kitchen and facilities.
Value
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
7.9Generally good value as many reviews indicated adequate pricing for services offered.
TCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
7.2Guests felt some amenities were overpriced given quality.
The Wild Peach - Menlyn
7.6Guests felt they received decent value, but there were complaints regarding room specifications not matching expectations.
Menlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
9.2Great value for the quality perceived in most reviews.
Landmarks
Circa Aparthotel by Totalstay
T.C. MitchellTCS on Lynnwood Guesthouse
T.C. MitchellThe Wild Peach - Menlyn
T.C. MitchellMenlyn Maine Luxury Apartments 11th & 14th floor with Balcony
Limited Access