Our pick
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star9.1/10990 reviews
0.06 km (0.04 mi) from original
English
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.4Spacious rooms and comfort noted in multiple reviews.
Cleanliness
8.5Many reviews noted cleanliness, but some mentioned issues during check-in.
Location
9.5Strategically located near attractions and conveniences.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.8/10242 reviews
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.4/10577 reviews
0.00 km (0.00 mi) from original
Our pick
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star9.1/10990 reviews
0.06 km (0.04 mi) from original
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.9/101,413 reviews
0.04 km (0.03 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites9.4
Bali Residence Impian Raudah8.0
Cleanliness
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites8.5
Bali Residence Impian Raudah7.0
Location
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management9.6
Bali Residence Impian Raudah9.1
Food & Breakfast
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management9.1
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites8.5
Value
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management9.1
Bali Residence Impian Raudah8.0
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay amenity advantages
Fitness/spa locker rooms
Bali Residence Impian Raudah amenity advantages
Concierge service
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites amenity advantages
Hot tub/Jacuzzi
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management amenity advantages
24-hour front desk
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.8/10Bali Residence Impian Raudah
8.4/10Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
9.1/10Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.9/10Rooms
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.3Mixed sentiments; some found rooms comfortable while others highlighted issues.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
8.0Room quality varied, some reported spaciousness while others mentioned dust and issues.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
9.4Spacious rooms and comfort noted in multiple reviews.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.1Some issues with room quality noted, including a lack of comfort and clean mattresses.
Cleanliness
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.3Some reviews mentioned the need for a deep clean and issues with odors.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
7.0Several reviews indicated issues with cleanliness, including dust and cockroaches.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
8.5Many reviews noted cleanliness, but some mentioned issues during check-in.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
7.6Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, including dirty floors and cockroaches.
Location
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
9.3The location was frequently praised for its convenience and proximity to amenities.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
9.1The location is often praised for its convenience to city centers and restaurants.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
9.5Strategically located near attractions and conveniences.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.6Location praised for its views and accessibility.
Service
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
9.3Guests appreciated the responsiveness of the host and helpful staff.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
9.5Most reviews mentioned helpful staff and good service.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
9.6Positive remarks about the helpfulness of staff and good service overall.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.6Good service highlighted by multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
—Bali Residence Impian Raudah
—Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
—Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
—Food & Breakfast
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.8Not explicitly mentioned, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
8.5Food in the cafe was noted as nice, contributing positively.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
8.5Some comments about lacking food options; potential for improvement.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.1Not much mentioned, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.8Facilities were generally good, though some basic amenities were missing.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
8.5Amenities such as a large pool and facilities were generally well-received.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
8.9Amenities were generally good, but some suggestions for improvement were made.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.6Facilities were generally good but some reviews mentioned needed upgrades.
Value
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
8.8General impression indicated fair pricing relative to provided services.
Bali Residence Impian Raudah
8.0Value varied; some felt it was high for the conditions experienced.
Atlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
8.9Generally perceived as good value, especially with the spacious accommodations.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.1Many guests felt it was affordable for families.
Landmarks
Bali Residence I Luxury 2BR I 6-10pax I Jonker St I Water Park I City Centre by Jay Stay
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingBali Residence Impian Raudah
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingAtlantis Residence 2BR and 3BR Family Suites
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingAtlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old Building