Our pick
English
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Rooms described as spacious and beautiful, but one comment about lacking a wardrobe.
Cleanliness
9.1Mentioned as clean, but there was a negative comment about a bad smell in the bathroom.
Location
10.0Good location noted in reviews, but one mention of being a bit far from amenities.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
Padang, ID
★ 0-star9.3/10190 reviews
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Amaris Hotel Padang10.0
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants8.1
Cleanliness
Mila Homestay9.5
Evergreen Lodge7.5
Location
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants10.0
Mila Homestay9.3
Food & Breakfast
Evergreen Lodge9.9
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants9.1
Value
Amaris Hotel Padang10.0
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants9.1
Evergreen Lodge amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerLaundryPets allowed
Amaris Hotel Padang amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceLift / ElevatorWheelchair accessibleMeeting/banquet facilities
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 4.8 km.
Evergreen Lodge: 1.8 km (1.1 mi)
Mila Homestay: 6.6 km (4.1 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
9.3/10Evergreen Lodge
9.2/10Amaris Hotel Padang
9.8/10Mila Homestay
9.6/10Rooms
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
8.1Mixed feedback; some rooms had issues such as no windows and cleanliness concerns.
Evergreen Lodge
8.4Rooms noted for being clean and comfortable, but cleanliness issues were also reported.
Amaris Hotel Padang
10.0Rooms described as spacious and beautiful, but one comment about lacking a wardrobe.
Mila Homestay
9.3Rooms are described as simple yet nicely furnished and comfortable.
Cleanliness
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
8.6Several mentions of dirtiness in shared bathrooms and overall cleanliness issues.
Evergreen Lodge
7.5Some cleanliness issues reported, including sour sheets and hair on the floor.
Amaris Hotel Padang
9.1Mentioned as clean, but there was a negative comment about a bad smell in the bathroom.
Mila Homestay
9.5Rooms are reported as spotless and very clean.
Location
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
10.0The hotel has a superb location with amazing views over the islands.
Evergreen Lodge
9.4Well-located with great views, although access can be challenging.
Amaris Hotel Padang
10.0Good location noted in reviews, but one mention of being a bit far from amenities.
Mila Homestay
9.3Beautiful and peaceful area overlooking the mountains with a feeling of being away from the city.
Service
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
10.0Staff were described as friendly and accommodating, with effort to assist guests, especially in ferry bookings.
Evergreen Lodge
9.9Staff are very friendly, welcoming, and helpful based on multiple reviews.
Amaris Hotel Padang
10.0Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
Mila Homestay
10.0Hosts are described as incredibly kind, hospitable, and always happy to help.
Sleep & Noise
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
—Evergreen Lodge
—Amaris Hotel Padang
—Mila Homestay
—Food & Breakfast
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
9.1Breakfast was noted as not great, influencing the overall food quality perception.
Evergreen Lodge
9.9Food praised, especially the pumpkin curry and breakfast options.
Amaris Hotel Padang
9.7Breakfast options were praised, but one mention of needing improvement.
Mila Homestay
9.8Breakfast is delicious and well-reviewed.
Amenities & Facilities
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
9.6Amenities like bike rentals and ferry bookings were praised, but some services fell short, like laundry.
Evergreen Lodge
9.4Facilities such as a roof terrace and good WiFi appreciated.
Amaris Hotel Padang
9.6Satisfactory amenities, although some issues with the breakfast options.
Mila Homestay
9.3Amenities are not specifically mentioned but implied to be sufficient for a pleasant stay.
Value
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
9.1Fair pricing but perceived as low quality regarding some services and cleanliness.
Evergreen Lodge
9.4Good value for quality received as per several comments.
Amaris Hotel Padang
10.0Positive comments suggest good value, with references to budget suitability.
Mila Homestay
9.7Good value for the price with great amenities.
Landmarks
The view padang, Amazing view, 8 mins Mentawai fast ferry, cold beer,close to restaurants
Monumen KapalEvergreen Lodge
StreetartAmaris Hotel Padang
Taman Tugu Air Mancur Rumah Gub. SumbarMila Homestay
Taman Kelurahan Cangkeh