
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Mostly positive feedback about comfort, though some room sizes were noted as small.
Cleanliness
8.3Some concerns about hair and cleanliness noted, impacting the rating.
Location
9.3Lovely location noted; ideal for exploration.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


St Austell, GB
1.4 km (0.86 mi) from original

St Austell, GB
4.1 km (2.6 mi) from original

The compared hotels differ by 2.7 km.
The White Hart Hotel: 1.4 km (0.86 mi)
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa: 4.1 km (2.6 mi)
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.5/10The White Hart Hotel
8.3/10The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9/10The Waterwheel
9.2/10The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Rooms were generally well-received, though issues with room configuration were noted.
The White Hart Hotel
8.1Rooms were comfortable and spacious, with warm ambiance.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
8.2Some dissatisfaction with small room size and bad view for certain guests.
The Waterwheel
8.8Mostly positive feedback about comfort, though some room sizes were noted as small.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
7.8Several comments noted dirty cutlery and crockery, affecting the overall impression of cleanliness.
The White Hart Hotel
8.0Clean and well-maintained rooms with friendly staff.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
8.2One review mentioned a dirty roof and standing water from the room.
The Waterwheel
8.3Some concerns about hair and cleanliness noted, impacting the rating.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8No issues mentioned; positive sentiment about location inferred from overall positive reviews.
The White Hart Hotel
8.5Central location near transportation and amenities.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Beautiful views and great location mentioned in several reviews.
The Waterwheel
9.3Lovely location noted; ideal for exploration.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8The staff were described as friendly and attentive, with some exceptions noted in isolated experiences.
The White Hart Hotel
8.4Staff were welcoming and helpful, with a special mention of attentive service.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.7Exceptional service praised throughout multiple reviews.
The Waterwheel
9.8Staff consistently described as friendly, accommodating, and helpful.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
—The White Hart Hotel
—The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
—The Waterwheel
—The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Overall good feedback on food quality; however, issues with service during meal times affected perception.
The White Hart Hotel
8.5Varied and delicious food options, with a special highlight on breakfast.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Food highly praised for quality and variety.
The Waterwheel
9.8High praise for food quality and variety.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.3Facilities like the spa were appreciated, though some comments indicated potential for improvement.
The White Hart Hotel
8.3Good amenities including a cozy lounge, breakfast service, and on-site dining.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Great amenities like pool, spa, and vegan breakfast mentioned positively.
The Waterwheel
9.3Beautiful gardens and outside areas contributed positively.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
8.8Guests felt value was acceptable given the general positives, though some questioned specifics.
The White Hart Hotel
8.4Excellent value with good quality service and offerings.
The Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
9.2Overall experience suggests the quality justifies the price.
The Waterwheel
8.8Well run hotel offering good value for money.
The Cornwall Hotel Spa & Lodges
Polgooth MineThe White Hart Hotel
There's No Place Like HomeThe Carlyon Bay Hotel and Spa
KidzworldThe Waterwheel
Cornish Honeybee