Odilia - Historic City Apartments - center of Brixen vs Similar Hotels

Generally good quality, but noted issues included missing amenities and lack of elevator.

Several guests enjoyed spacious, comfortable rooms; however repeated issues (no air conditioning, dated fixtures, worn carpet, narrow/heavy bedding, TV/connectivity problems, windows/insulation issues) lower this score.

Rooms described as outdated in some reviews.

Rooms described as beautiful, comfortable, and spacious, enhancing the overall comfort of the stay.

Some cleanliness concerns were mentioned, including poor hygiene and missing cleaning products.

Rooms and hotel described as clean in multiple reviews, with explicit praise for hygiene and cleanliness; a few guests noted dated carpet and an unpleasant odor in some rooms, so slightly below top marks.

Issues with cleanliness mentioned, such as a clogged bathtub.

Consistently praised for cleanliness, with specific mentions of rooms being very clean and well maintained.

Many reviews highlighted the exceptional central location as a major positive.

Numerous reviewers cite an excellent/central location and quiet surroundings — consistently praised across languages, supporting a very strong rating.

Multiple reviews praised the central location.

Location frequently mentioned as excellent, being central and convenient for visiting the historic area.

Good communication with the host prior to arrival, although there were issues with responsiveness during the stay.

Staff repeatedly described as courteous, friendly and helpful (including empathetic assistance after a car breakdown); multiple mentions of excellent, accommodating personnel justify a high score.

Generally positive, but one comment on unfriendly reception.

Service highlighted as warm, attentive, and genuinely kind, contributing significantly to the overall experience.

No specific concerns were raised regarding food and beverage, categorized as standard for this hotel tier.

Breakfast repeatedly described as excellent, very varied and among the best guests have had — consistently strong positive sentiment supports a top score.

Breakfast praised, but some issues with buffet layout.

Breakfast praised for high-quality local products, although some guests expected more variety.

Some amenities were lacking, such as items in the kitchen and functioning equipment.

Notable amenity gaps reported: absence of air conditioning in many rooms, few/no in-room extras (kettle, shampoo), snack machine missing, and the pool/hallenbad located in another building ~150 m away — weakens this category.

Pools and spa facilities received positive feedback.

Amenities noted include a rooftop swimming pool and spa services, positively impacting guest experiences.

Considered reasonable for the price given the location, but some felt improvements could be made.

Mixed signals: excellent breakfast and good location provide value, but lack of AC, need for renovation and missing amenities led some guests to feel the hotel is not fully justified for the price.

Mixed feedback on pricing during the holiday period.

Some guests felt the breakfast could be improved for the price, affecting perceived value.