Our pick
English
St. Ives Holiday Village vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.6The bed was very comfortable with a good amount of amenities.
Cleanliness
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Service
10.0Staff were lovely and attentive.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Gannet Inn9.6
St. Ives Holiday Village7.5
Cleanliness
The Gannet Inn9.1
St. Ives Holiday Village6.6
Location
Pedn-Olva9.8
The Gannet Inn8.5
Service
The Gannet Inn10.0
St. Ives Holiday Village8.5
Food & Breakfast
The Countryman9.6
St. Ives Holiday Village7.1
Amenities & Facilities
The Countryman9.6
St. Ives Holiday Village7.0
Value
The Gannet Inn9.5
St. Ives Holiday Village7.5
St. Ives Holiday Village amenity advantages
Swimming poolSaunaElectric vehicle charging station
The Gannet Inn amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceSpa/wellness centerLuggage storageMeeting/banquet facilities
Pedn-Olva amenity advantages
Laundry
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.0 km.
The Countryman: 2.2 km (1.4 mi)
Pedn-Olva: 4.2 km (2.6 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
St. Ives Holiday Village
7.6/10The Gannet Inn
9.4/10The Countryman
9.2/10Pedn-Olva
9/10Rooms
St. Ives Holiday Village
7.5Mixed sentiments on room quality; some aspects noted as comfortable but issues with cleanliness.
The Gannet Inn
9.6The bed was very comfortable with a good amount of amenities.
The Countryman
8.6While rooms were generally clean, some reviews indicated that furnishings are outdated.
Pedn-Olva
8.3Generally lovely rooms, but many complaints about room size.
Cleanliness
St. Ives Holiday Village
6.6Multiple mentions of dirtiness in accommodations; specific areas noted as needing more cleaning.
The Gannet Inn
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Countryman
8.6Some reviews mention that the hotel didn't leave a very neat and tidy impression and noted dust in the room.
Pedn-Olva
8.3Standard quality for this hotel tier, some concerns about room size affecting perceived cleanliness.
Location
St. Ives Holiday Village
8.6Location is consistently praised across reviews; lovely wooded area.
The Gannet Inn
8.5Located on a busy road, not close to the village.
The Countryman
9.6The hotel is well-located for exploring St Ives and offers good parking.
Pedn-Olva
9.8Exceptional views and a great location highlighted by many guests.
Service
St. Ives Holiday Village
8.5Staff were polite and responsive; positive interactions noted.
The Gannet Inn
10.0Staff were lovely and attentive.
The Countryman
9.6Many reviews highlight the hosts as friendly, accommodating, and attentive.
Pedn-Olva
9.8Fantastic staff and friendly service noted in multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
St. Ives Holiday Village
—The Gannet Inn
—The Countryman
—Pedn-Olva
—Food & Breakfast
St. Ives Holiday Village
7.1Limited feedback, noted that the restaurant environment did not seem appealing.
The Gannet Inn
9.0Food was excellent, but some items could be improved.
The Countryman
9.6Breakfast received high praise as being very good with a variety of choices.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Breakfast was nice, but evening meals were noted as poor by one guest.
Amenities & Facilities
St. Ives Holiday Village
7.0Amenities such as the pool were criticized (freezing water), with requests for better facilities.
The Gannet Inn
9.5Spa facilities available, well received by guests.
The Countryman
9.6Guests enjoyed the garden, lounge, and facilities offered.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Good facilities overall, though some amenities like coffee availability at breakfast were lacking.
Value
St. Ives Holiday Village
7.5Seen as home away from home for the price, but some value concerns with cleanliness.
The Gannet Inn
9.5Guests noted overall satisfaction with the experience relative to price.
The Countryman
8.5Some reviews suggest that value for money was not ideal due to cleanliness and outdated furnishings.
Pedn-Olva
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier, considering the location and views.
Landmarks
St. Ives Holiday Village
War MemorialThe Gannet Inn
Menhyr ParkThe Countryman
Knill's MonumentPedn-Olva
Epidauros II