
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.4Guests enjoyed the character and comfort of the rooms, citing memories of a charming atmosphere.
Cleanliness
8.4The room was noted as clean and comfortable, but some reviews mentioned issues with food quality.
Location
9.9Multiple reviews highlighted the perfect location of the hotel, making it a strong positive aspect.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.7/10Lil's On The Waterfront
7/10Golden Fleece York
9.1/10Guy Fawkes Inn
8.2/10Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.5Rooms were mostly appreciated for their comfort and cleanliness, with small issues noted.
Lil's On The Waterfront
6.0Some rooms were described as unfit for stay, but there were also mentions of comfortable rooms.
Golden Fleece York
9.4Guests enjoyed the character and comfort of the rooms, citing memories of a charming atmosphere.
Guy Fawkes Inn
7.6Some rooms were noisy and in need of maintenance, impacting overall comfort.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.3Overall cleanliness was noted as spotless, but attention to detail could have been better.
Lil's On The Waterfront
5.1Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, including filthy conditions and the need for deep cleaning.
Golden Fleece York
8.4The room was noted as clean and comfortable, but some reviews mentioned issues with food quality.
Guy Fawkes Inn
7.7While toilets were clean, some areas like lighting and bathrooms need attention.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
9.1Amazing and very central location in York, close to attractions.
Lil's On The Waterfront
8.6Multiple reviews positively highlighted the great location near amenities and the river.
Golden Fleece York
9.9Multiple reviews highlighted the perfect location of the hotel, making it a strong positive aspect.
Guy Fawkes Inn
9.2Hotel is perfectly located for visiting the city and includes historic charm.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
9.1Staff were described as super helpful and friendly, providing a great experience.
Lil's On The Waterfront
8.1Positive sentiments noted regarding the staff's helpfulness and friendliness.
Golden Fleece York
9.4Staff received positive comments, being described as fun, friendly, and accommodating throughout the reviews.
Guy Fawkes Inn
8.6Staff were described as friendly and helpful throughout the stay.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
—Lil's On The Waterfront
—Golden Fleece York
—Guy Fawkes Inn
—Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.8Breakfast was noted as brilliant with a lot of choice.
Lil's On The Waterfront
7.6Breakfast and food options received positive remarks, though there were some logistical concerns.
Golden Fleece York
7.9Food quality had mixed reviews; while breakfast was praised, some dining experiences were disappointing.
Guy Fawkes Inn
8.2Food generally good, but specific dishes received mixed reviews.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.6General amenities were included, though specific mentions were limited.
Lil's On The Waterfront
6.6Amenities received mixed reviews; some were satisfactory, others outdated or broken.
Golden Fleece York
8.9Amenities were overall positive; however, specific offerings were not deeply detailed in reviews.
Guy Fawkes Inn
8.2Amenities present but lacking in some toiletries and additional comforts.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
8.5Good value for the price, including breakfast.
Lil's On The Waterfront
7.0The pricing was mentioned positively, especially in relation to location and some services.
Golden Fleece York
9.4Guests felt they got great value, especially for the charming experience provided.
Guy Fawkes Inn
7.6Guests felt that certain aspects, like food pricing, were not worth the cost.
Galtres Lodge Hotel & Forest Restaurant
PetergateLil's On The Waterfront
Cumberland HouseGolden Fleece York
Joseph RowntreeGuy Fawkes Inn
Norman House