
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.7Clean and comfortable rooms, but some concerns about noise and lighting.
Cleanliness
8.7Generally clean but mentions of subpar bathroom lighting and rooms not being serviced.
Location
10.0Excellent location in Old San Juan, very convenient for guests.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




San Juan, PR
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
SJ SUITES HOTEL
7.8/10Navona Studios
8.4/10Decanter Hotel
9.2/10La Capitana Old San Juan Building
6.8/10SJ SUITES HOTEL
7.0Rooms described as small, dark, and lacking modern amenities, with specific complaints about noise and temperature control.
Navona Studios
8.2Rooms were clean but had noise issues and some requested features weren't met.
Decanter Hotel
8.7Clean and comfortable rooms, but some concerns about noise and lighting.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
6.2Rooms were generally acceptable, though there were complaints about missing items and small bathrooms.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
7.1Several comments noted issues with cleanliness, such as the carpet being disgusting and leftovers from previous guests.
Navona Studios
8.2Generally clean with some complaints about the shower and condition of bathrooms.
Decanter Hotel
8.7Generally clean but mentions of subpar bathroom lighting and rooms not being serviced.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
5.7The cleanliness was criticized due to infrequent cleaning and issues such as unclean floors and stained mattresses.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
10.0Location was frequently praised as excellent and convenient for exploring Old San Juan.
Navona Studios
9.2Exceptional location close to the center and attractions.
Decanter Hotel
10.0Excellent location in Old San Juan, very convenient for guests.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
8.7Multiple reviews highlighted the excellent location and scenic views.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
9.1Most reviews highlighted friendly staff and accommodating service, though there were some issues with getting rooms ready.
Navona Studios
8.7Staff was described positively, but there were some inconsistencies.
Decanter Hotel
10.0Staff consistently described as friendly and helpful, enhancing the overall experience.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
7.7The staff was described as friendly and helpful, but there were some negative comments about service responsiveness.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
—Navona Studios
—Decanter Hotel
—La Capitana Old San Juan Building
—SJ SUITES HOTEL
6.1No food or beverage options were provided, and breakfast was not included.
Navona Studios
8.2No breakfast provided; some concerns about dining availability in the area.
Decanter Hotel
8.7Rooftop restaurant closed, impacting dining options during stay.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
6.7No specific mentions, considered standard for the region.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
6.6Limited amenities were a common complaint, such as the lack of in-room tea/coffee and breakfast.
Navona Studios
7.7No elevator and limited breakfast options were mentioned.
Decanter Hotel
8.7Nice rooftop area but limited functional amenities like breakfast.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
5.7Lack of basic amenities like microwaves and insufficient kitchen supplies were noted.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
8.5Value was considered decent for the location; however, expectations for comfort and cleanliness lowered the perceived value.
Navona Studios
8.7Good value considering the location and overall experience.
Decanter Hotel
8.7Concerns expressed regarding the value versus product offered.
La Capitana Old San Juan Building
7.1Value perception varies; some found it decent for the price, while others expected better due to various issues.
SJ SUITES HOTEL
Plaza Salvador BrauNavona Studios
Plaza Salvador BrauDecanter Hotel
Bandera NegraLa Capitana Old San Juan Building
Placita Ismael Rivera