
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.6Rooms are noted as comfortable and spacious, though some had minor issues.
Cleanliness
8.6Many reviews highlight that rooms and common areas were clean and well-maintained.
Service
8.9Several reviews mention responsive and helpful owners and staff.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Forss House
8.6/10Sandras Backpackers
7/10Pentland Hotel
7.7/10The View from BIDE
8.7/10Forss House
8.9Rooms described as lovely and comfortable.
Sandras Backpackers
5.6Concerns were raised about the quality of the rooms, especially regarding safety and comfort.
Pentland Hotel
7.6Rooms generally rated well but some described as basic and needing improvement.
The View from BIDE
8.6Rooms are noted as comfortable and spacious, though some had minor issues.
Forss House
7.9Some issues with details and maintenance were noted.
Sandras Backpackers
6.1There were issues mentioned with the bathroom cleanliness and water on the floor.
Pentland Hotel
6.6Some reviews highlight unclean rooms, including dirty areas and inadequate shower facilities.
The View from BIDE
8.6Many reviews highlight that rooms and common areas were clean and well-maintained.
Forss House
9.4Great location, very private and scenic.
Sandras Backpackers
8.7The location was described as very good, being close to the railway station.
Pentland Hotel
7.1Mixed feedback; while the hotel is centrally located, some reviews describe the surrounding area negatively.
The View from BIDE
8.8Guests frequently comment on the great location and easy access to public transport.
Forss House
8.9Service was friendly but there were some issues with training.
Sandras Backpackers
6.6Mixed reviews on service, with some positive notes but significant dissatisfaction during check-in.
Pentland Hotel
8.6Many reviews mention exceptional staff and helpful service, particularly during difficult situations.
The View from BIDE
8.9Several reviews mention responsive and helpful owners and staff.
Forss House
—Sandras Backpackers
—Pentland Hotel
—The View from BIDE
—Forss House
8.4Great meals but issues with menu availability.
Sandras Backpackers
7.6Small breakfast offered, but variation and quality depend on guest behavior.
Pentland Hotel
7.6Food quality mixed; breakfast praised but some dinner experiences noted as poor.
The View from BIDE
8.6No specific comments, so rated as standard quality for this hotel tier.
Forss House
8.4Adequate amenities, though service at the restaurant needs improvement.
Sandras Backpackers
7.1Basic amenities provided, though some guests found the breakfast and cleanliness dependent on the guests.
Pentland Hotel
8.1The hotel offers satisfactory amenities, including heating and breakfast options.
The View from BIDE
8.7The availability of amenities like fridge, coffee machine, and good wifi is appreciated.
Forss House
7.9Some guests felt it was overpriced given the experience.
Sandras Backpackers
7.1The cost was seen as low but the value was questioned due to multiple negative aspects of the stay.
Pentland Hotel
8.5Several reviews confirm good value for the price paid, especially with breakfast included.
The View from BIDE
8.8Most guests feel the price is fair for the quality and location of the accommodation.
Forss House
Tulloch of Lybster, BrochSandras Backpackers
Sir George Sinclair Memorial FountainPentland Hotel
Sir George Sinclair Memorial FountainThe View from BIDE
Old St. Peter's Kirk