
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
New York, US
0.85 km (0.53 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

New York, US
0.85 km (0.53 mi) from original
Rooms
8.9Rooms mentioned as lovely and comfortable, though in need of some renovation.
Cleanliness
8.0Some reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness.
Location
9.4Guests frequently praised the hotel's prime location.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



New York, US
0.85 km (0.53 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 0.84 km.
The Renwick: 0.13 km (0.08 mi)
Pod 51: 0.97 km (0.60 mi)
Pod 39
8.4/10The Renwick
8.6/10Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.8/10Pod 51
8.1/10Pod 39
7.6Many reviews express rooms are small and lack some modern amenities.
The Renwick
7.9Issues with room maintenance mentioned, but some positive remarks on spaciousness.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.9Rooms mentioned as lovely and comfortable, though in need of some renovation.
Pod 51
7.4Rooms are small and some are noisy.
Pod 39
8.2Reviews indicate overall cleanliness is good, but some guests noted issues like small bathrooms and lack of privacy.
The Renwick
7.5Multiple mentions of dirty rooms and poor cleanliness standards noted.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.0Some reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness.
Pod 51
7.5Some guests mentioned concerns about unclean bathrooms.
Pod 39
9.2Ideal location mentioned multiple times, close to key attractions.
The Renwick
9.5Strong emphasis on excellent location and accessibility.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
9.4Guests frequently praised the hotel's prime location.
Pod 51
9.0The hotel is in an excellent and convenient location.
Pod 39
9.2Consistently praised as super cordial across several reviews.
The Renwick
9.4Generally positive comments about staff friendliness and willingness to assist.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
9.4Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
Pod 51
8.4Many reviews praised the attentive staff.
Pod 39
—The Renwick
—Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
—Pod 51
—Pod 39
8.7Complimentary coffee and tea appreciated; good breakfast options mentioned.
The Renwick
9.0Positive notes on available breakfast coffee and bar experience.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.4Mentioned in a review as needing improvement with breakfast options.
Pod 51
8.0No specific mentions; assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Pod 39
8.7Good amenities like a gym, bar/restaurant, and rooftop, but some rooms lack storage.
The Renwick
8.5No significant negatives mentioned; some amenities met expectations.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.0Some guests noted the lack of amenities in the room.
Pod 51
8.0Basic amenities are available; some guests experienced minor issues.
Pod 39
7.1Several comments suggest the price may be too high for the small room sizes.
The Renwick
7.9Comments suggest a perception of overpricing relative to the quality provided.
Hilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
8.9Most reviews indicate satisfaction with value, though some noted pricing issues.
Pod 51
8.4Good value for the location, even with some drawbacks.
Pod 39
Strange Days Album Cover LocationThe Renwick
Pershing SquareHilton Garden Inn West 35th Street
Herald SquarePod 51
Greenacre Park