Asiatic Hotel - Flushing vs Similar Hotels

Rooms generally comfortable and clean with comfortable beds, but several comments about small rooms, inconsistent in-room fridges/microwaves, audible adjacent rooms and an older AC model limited the rating.

The room was described as extremely cold.

Generally spacious and comfortable rooms, though some mention noise issues.

Some comments highlight the room's comfort but others point out issues like soft mattresses and inadequate amenities.

Multiple reviewers repeatedly praised the cleanliness of rooms and lobby; rooms described as very clean and well maintained.

The property was described as clean.

Some reviews indicate missing room cleaning during long stays.

Multiple reviews indicated concerns with cleanliness, including strange odors and issues with water leaks.

Excellent location noted repeatedly — close to trains, restaurants and Flushing Chinatown with easy access to local attractions; some reviewers mentioned constant airplane noise due to proximity to airport.

Convenient location near subway and restaurants.

Conveniently located near LaGuardia with easy access to restaurants and transportation.

Positive feedback on the location being convenient and close to public transport and shopping.

Front desk and many staff described as helpful and professional, but there were reports of rude housekeeping and language/communication issues that lowered this score slightly.

Staff were friendly and accommodating.

Overall friendly staff, positive experiences reported at the front desk.

Some guests reported professional and helpful service, though there were also negative experiences mentioned.

Breakfast experiences varied: some guests called it delicious with variety, while others reported very limited options (esp. for non-Asian preferences), cold eggs and lacking hot milk or multiple juice options.

Breakfast options were limited and repetitive.

Positive remarks about breakfast quality but limited information on other food options.

Multiple reviews criticized the lack of variety in breakfast offerings.

Amenities were mixed: included breakfast for some, but inconsistent in-room appliances (fridge/microwave), poor/inconsistent WiFi reported, and lack of designated parking/loading area impacted the score.

Basic amenities offered; concerns about breakfast quality.

Good amenities with kitchen facilities; some missing details regarding necessary kitchenware.

Noted issues with amenities such as the coffee maker not working and limited breakfast variety.

Multiple reviewers cited the hotel as relatively affordable for NYC with good overall quality for the price; described as reasonable and good value.

Good price for location; some amenities could improve.

Good value especially with competitive pricing in New York.

Mixed sentiments about value; some thought it was fair while others found it lacking due to additional fees.