
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.2Rooms were described as comfortable and modern, though some appeared dated.
Cleanliness
9.2The hotel was described as very clean in multiple reviews.
Location
9.3The hotel is in a convenient location close to attractions.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Dunbar, GB
1.9 km (1.2 mi) from original

The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel: 0.81 km (0.51 mi)
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns: 1.9 km (1.2 mi)
Bayswell Park Hotel
8.4/10Royal Mackintosh Hotel
8.2/10Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.1/10Dunmuir Hotel
9.4/10Bayswell Park Hotel
7.9Comfortable room but noted decor needs updating.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
7.2Rooms were described as basic, tired, and in need of updating.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
7.8Comfortable and warm rooms with good facilities.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.2Rooms were described as comfortable and modern, though some appeared dated.
Bayswell Park Hotel
7.4Mentioned issue with shower facilities indicates potential cleanliness concerns.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
7.7Some guests indicated the rooms were tired and had damp smells.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
6.8Mixed reviews; mentioned poor cleaning standards.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.2The hotel was described as very clean in multiple reviews.
Bayswell Park Hotel
8.9Location is praised for direct access to the sea and fabulous views.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
9.2Many reviews highlighted the central location, close to the train station and other attractions.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.5Great location, easy to find, and convenient.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.3The hotel is in a convenient location close to attractions.
Bayswell Park Hotel
8.9Staff were described as very friendly and accommodating, though there was a significant negative review regarding service.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
9.2Guests consistently praised the friendly and helpful staff.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.8Staff were described as very helpful and friendly.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.7Staff were repeatedly praised for being friendly and helpful.
Bayswell Park Hotel
—Royal Mackintosh Hotel
—Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
—Dunmuir Hotel
—Bayswell Park Hotel
8.9Food options were highly praised with specific recommendations.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
8.7Food and beverage options were generally well-received, though some service issues were noted.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.6Food quality and dining experience were highly praised.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.7Breakfast was highlighted as excellent and satisfying.
Bayswell Park Hotel
7.9Incredible views and hot tub mentioned positively, though some minor issues noted.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
7.7Limited amenities mentioned, such as the lack of Wi-Fi and limited sockets.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.0Facilities mentioned positively, though more sockets are needed.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.2Amenities such as Wi-Fi and breakfast options received positive comments.
Bayswell Park Hotel
8.9Described as superb value for money with an excellent breakfast.
Royal Mackintosh Hotel
7.7Some guests expressed that the hotel was not worth the cost due to outdated conditions.
Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
8.2Good pricing noted; generally perceived as a good value.
Dunmuir Hotel
9.2The price was considered good for what was offered, despite some mentioning it was a bit on the higher side.
Bayswell Park Hotel
The GlebeRoyal Mackintosh Hotel
Abbey Church (deconsecrated)Pine Marten, Dunbar by Marston's Inns
Dunbar BearDunmuir Hotel
Newhouse Farm Steading Horsemill