
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
7.7Concerns about room conditions such as humidity and mattress quality were noted.
Cleanliness
7.7Several reviews mentioned issues with room cleanliness, such as humidity and service delays.
Location
9.2Applauded for being close to the beach and restaurants.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


San Andrés, CO
0.21 km (0.13 mi) from original


San Andrés, CO
0.39 km (0.25 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Hotel El Dorado
7.4/10Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
7.7/10Hotel Casablanca
8.2/10Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.3/10Hotel El Dorado
8.1Rooms in the new tower are well-received, but older tower rooms were criticized.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
7.7Comfortable room mentioned, but issues with amenities reduce the rating.
Hotel Casablanca
7.7Concerns about room conditions such as humidity and mattress quality were noted.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.3Rooms are described as cozy and well-equipped, but there were mentions of issues like late cleaning.
Hotel El Dorado
6.7Pool cleanliness issues and reports of unclean rooms.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
7.2Issues with room flooding and lack of internet indicate cleanliness concerns.
Hotel Casablanca
7.7Several reviews mentioned issues with room cleanliness, such as humidity and service delays.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
4.9Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness, such as dirty sheets and the pool being out of service.
Hotel El Dorado
9.2Excellent location with easy access to the beach and nearby amenities.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
8.7Location near the beach and central amenities positively highlighted.
Hotel Casablanca
9.2Applauded for being close to the beach and restaurants.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.9The location is praised for being centrally located, although some reviews mention it may not be ideal for older guests.
Hotel El Dorado
8.2Generally good service, but some negative experiences with restaurant staff.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
8.2Staff is generally described as attentive and friendly, boosting service rating.
Hotel Casablanca
8.7Many positive comments regarding the friendly and helpful staff.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
8.3Reviews generally express positive feelings towards staff attentiveness, despite some incidents of poor service.
Hotel El Dorado
—Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
—Hotel Casablanca
—Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
—Hotel El Dorado
5.7Food quality and variety were heavily criticized across multiple reviews.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
6.7Food variety and quality, especially for breakfast, described as lacking.
Hotel Casablanca
8.7Breakfast was well received, noted as one of the best on the island.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
8.9The food consistently receives high praise for quality and variety.
Hotel El Dorado
6.7Some amenities like the buffet were subpar; all-inclusive not recommended.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
7.2Limited options available at the buffet and missing entertainment activities.
Hotel Casablanca
8.2Facilities were generally commendable, but improvements noted for offered amenities.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
5.9Amenities were a mixed bag; although the pool is appreciated, other amenities like the gym were out of order.
Hotel El Dorado
7.1Guests felt they didn't receive good value for what they paid.
Hotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
7.7Value questioned due to size of the hotel and service level not matching the price.
Hotel Casablanca
7.2Comments regarding high prices compared to the perceived value of services offered.
Hotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
7.8Many guests feel the overall value is good considering the price.
Hotel El Dorado
Parque La BarracudaHotel Arena Blanca by Dorado
Crucero rivielHotel Casablanca
Cañon de MorganHotel Portobelo Plaza las Ámericas
Cañon de Morgan