
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.6Rooms are described as comfortable, though some mentioned issues with lighting.
Cleanliness
8.1Some reviews mentioned cobwebs and limited attention to detail.
Location
9.1Excellent location for visiting Matlock and exploring local attractions.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Matlock, GB
3.4 km (2.1 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.3 km.
The Red Lion: 1.1 km (0.67 mi)
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals: 3.4 km (2.1 mi)
Duke of Wellington
7.6/10The Red Lion
8.7/10High Tor Hotel
7.6/10New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
8/10Duke of Wellington
7.4Some rooms noted as comfortable, but others mentioned issues like coldness and shabbiness.
The Red Lion
8.6Rooms are described as comfortable, though some mentioned issues with lighting.
High Tor Hotel
7.0Rooms were comfortable but some felt cramped and had issues with furniture layout.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
7.8Rooms described as dated and below standard, needing improvement.
Duke of Wellington
7.0Some reviews mention cleanliness issues, such as mould and cobwebs.
The Red Lion
8.1Some reviews mentioned cobwebs and limited attention to detail.
High Tor Hotel
7.5Some concerns about cleanliness with missing toilet roll holder and items not replaced promptly.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
7.3Mentioned as run down and old with stains everywhere, alluding to poor cleaning.
Duke of Wellington
8.5Location is appreciated, with mentions of walking distance to town.
The Red Lion
9.1Excellent location for visiting Matlock and exploring local attractions.
High Tor Hotel
8.5Great location close to town and local attractions, easy to navigate.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
9.3Highly praised for convenience and access to attractions.
Duke of Wellington
8.9Multiple reviews highlight staff as friendly and helpful.
The Red Lion
9.1Staff are consistently described as friendly and helpful.
High Tor Hotel
8.5Staff were friendly and helpful, but there were reports of insufficient staff during peak times.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
8.8Staff were friendly and accommodating, though some noted inexperience.
Duke of Wellington
—The Red Lion
—High Tor Hotel
—New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
—Duke of Wellington
8.5Food quality is frequently praised, although kitchen hours are limited.
The Red Lion
9.1Food received high praise, particularly breakfast and Sunday carvery.
High Tor Hotel
6.0Breakfast variety was considered poor and disappointing by some guests.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
6.8Breakfast options were limited and of below-average quality.
Duke of Wellington
8.0Amenities described positively, though some improvements needed for things like hooks.
The Red Lion
8.6Amenities available but varied, with some mentioning limited TV channels.
High Tor Hotel
8.0Well-equipped with parking, but some amenities underutilized or not commented on.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
8.3Good amenities like a pool but issues noted regarding service and cleanliness.
Duke of Wellington
7.9Good value for price, particularly during holiday seasons.
The Red Lion
8.6Generally described as good value, with enjoyable meals and drinks.
High Tor Hotel
7.4Prices seemed high compared to the range and quality offered, particularly for breakfast.
New Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
7.8Some guests felt the cost was high for the offered quality.
Duke of Wellington
Asker Lane FieldsThe Red Lion
Hall Leys ParkHigh Tor Hotel
High TorNew Bath Hotel & Spa, a member of Radisson Individuals
Temple Mine