Hilton Garden Inn New York Manhattan Midtown East - Newly Renovated vs Similar Hotels

Some complaints about room size and mattress quality; however, many find the rooms cozy.

Rooms are small and some are noisy.

Rooms mentioned as lovely and comfortable, though in need of some renovation.

Some complaints regarding room size and noise levels, but overall satisfactory.

Mixed reviews regarding cleanliness; some guests found issues with room space and mattress quality.

Some guests mentioned concerns about unclean bathrooms.

Some reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness.

Multiple guests reported issues with cleanliness, including finding a cockroach and inadequate housekeeping.

Numerous positives about the location being safe and close to attractions and metro stations.

The hotel is in an excellent and convenient location.

Guests frequently praised the hotel's prime location.

The location is frequently praised as excellent, ideal for sightseeing and access to various attractions.

Generally positive comments on staff being friendly and accommodating, except for some issues with front desk behavior.

Many reviews praised the attentive staff.

Staff were described as friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.

Most guests mentioned friendly and accommodating staff, enhancing the overall experience.

Breakfast in the café was described as convenient, although not extensively reviewed.

No specific mentions; assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.

Mentioned in a review as needing improvement with breakfast options.

Issues with breakfast options and service comfort noted in reviews.

Amenities such as fridge and coffee pot are appreciated, but some guests noted the need for upgrades.

Basic amenities are available; some guests experienced minor issues.

Some guests noted the lack of amenities in the room.

Facilities are generally good but with some shortcomings like breakfast options.

Perceived as good value by many; however, some guests felt dissatisfied with mattress quality.

Good value for the location, even with some drawbacks.

Most reviews indicate satisfaction with value, though some noted pricing issues.

Value is seen as average due to mixed reviews about service and amenities.