
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.3Some comments about basic room quality and small size.
Cleanliness
8.4A few reviews indicated cleanliness issues, though many mentioned the room was clean.
Location
9.4Multiple mentions of great locations, easy access to city center.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




The Sycamore Guest House
8.9/10Gillygate Guest House
8.7/10St. Raphael Guest House
9/10Brentwood Guest House
8.4/10The Sycamore Guest House
8.7Warm and cosy room with a very comfortable bed.
Gillygate Guest House
8.6Rooms described as clean, comfortable, and well-equipped.
St. Raphael Guest House
8.3Some comments about basic room quality and small size.
Brentwood Guest House
8.4Rooms are clean and comfortable, though some had minor issues with temperature.
The Sycamore Guest House
8.7The house was very clean and the owner very welcoming.
Gillygate Guest House
8.1Mention of cleanliness in reviews, but some concerns noted.
St. Raphael Guest House
8.4A few reviews indicated cleanliness issues, though many mentioned the room was clean.
Brentwood Guest House
7.9Generally clean, but some comments indicated noise and thin walls which implied issues.
The Sycamore Guest House
9.2Great location, only 10 min walk along the river to York centre.
Gillygate Guest House
9.1Fabulous location, central and close to attractions.
St. Raphael Guest House
9.4Multiple mentions of great locations, easy access to city center.
Brentwood Guest House
8.9Great location with easy access to town center and attractions.
The Sycamore Guest House
9.4Extremely friendly hosts and couldn’t do enough for us.
Gillygate Guest House
9.1Positive mentions of friendly and helpful hosts.
St. Raphael Guest House
9.4Consistently positive comments about friendly and helpful staff.
Brentwood Guest House
8.7Overall positive feedback on staff, indicating helpfulness and friendliness.
The Sycamore Guest House
—Gillygate Guest House
—St. Raphael Guest House
—Brentwood Guest House
—The Sycamore Guest House
9.2Delicious cooked breakfast.
Gillygate Guest House
8.6Positive feedback on breakfast options.
St. Raphael Guest House
8.9Reviews highlight good breakfast, but a few issues noted with certain food options.
Brentwood Guest House
8.3No specific comments on food and beverage offerings, assigned target rating.
The Sycamore Guest House
8.8Amenities were adequate and well-maintained.
Gillygate Guest House
8.6Good amenities but could be improved.
St. Raphael Guest House
9.4Good amenities like breakfast and parking were praised.
Brentwood Guest House
8.1Amenities were mentioned positively, but some comments noted possible improvements.
The Sycamore Guest House
8.2Somewhat poor value for money mentioned, but nothing major.
Gillygate Guest House
8.6Good value for the location and service received.
St. Raphael Guest House
8.8General satisfaction with value, but some felt prices were on the higher side.
Brentwood Guest House
8.5Guests felt they received good value for the price paid.
The Sycamore Guest House
Stephen Pit CorderGillygate Guest House
Second DivisionSt. Raphael Guest House
Stephen Pit CorderBrentwood Guest House
NHS Mural