
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
St Lucia, ZA
0.35 km (0.22 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

St Lucia, ZA
0.35 km (0.22 mi) from original
Rooms
7.9Rooms are spacious but some furniture and fixtures are dated and require maintenance.
Cleanliness
7.9Clean and neat, but occasionally issues like shower quality and cleanliness mentioned.
Location
9.4Great location, central and close to amenities.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



St Lucia, ZA
0.35 km (0.22 mi) from original

First Group Lake View Cabanas
8.4/10St Lucia Palms
7.7/10Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
8.6/10Elephant Lake Hotel
7.7/10First Group Lake View Cabanas
8.0Rooms were mentioned as nice, but maintenance issues were noted.
St Lucia Palms
6.5Issues with room allocation and cramped spaces were highlighted in multiple reviews.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
7.9Rooms are spacious but some furniture and fixtures are dated and require maintenance.
Elephant Lake Hotel
7.0Rooms were basic and lacking some amenities for a 4-star hotel.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
7.6Several reviews mentioned dirty rooms and inadequate cleaning services.
St Lucia Palms
7.0Several reviews indicated issues with cleanliness, including mold in the shower.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
7.9Clean and neat, but occasionally issues like shower quality and cleanliness mentioned.
Elephant Lake Hotel
8.0Room was clean and the property was very clean and comfortable to stay in.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
9.1Positive feedback on the property's convenient location close to attractions.
St Lucia Palms
9.4The hotel is conveniently located near the beach and shops, which was positively noted.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
9.4Great location, central and close to amenities.
Elephant Lake Hotel
8.4Location was exceptional and next to all restaurants and bars.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
9.0Multiple guests praised the staff for being helpful and welcoming.
St Lucia Palms
8.4Staff were friendly but some interactions were reported as cold or lacking warmth.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
9.4Friendly staff and helpful management, although some issues with communication were noted.
Elephant Lake Hotel
8.4Staff were friendly and helpful, providing a warm and welcoming experience.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
—St Lucia Palms
—Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
—Elephant Lake Hotel
—First Group Lake View Cabanas
8.6Not specifically mentioned, assumed standard for hotel tier.
St Lucia Palms
6.5No specific food and beverage comments; treated as a lower rating due to lack of amenities for cooking.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
8.4Not specifically mentioned, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Elephant Lake Hotel
6.5Breakfast was basic and dinner buffet was poor for the price.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
8.1Good amenities like a pool and games room but some need renovation.
St Lucia Palms
8.0Amenities were generally considered adequate, though some basic kitchen supplies were missing.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
8.4Well equipped with necessary amenities but lacks some extra touches.
Elephant Lake Hotel
7.5Basic amenities with room for improvement, such as the lack of DSTV and a limited restaurant service.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
8.5Generally viewed as good value, but some concerns about cleanliness bring it down.
St Lucia Palms
8.4Generally recognized as good value for money despite some shortcomings.
Perna Perna Lodge St Lucia
8.4Good value but some complaints about maintenance suggested room for improvement.
Elephant Lake Hotel
8.0Provided reasonable value with notable positives, but some amenities were lacking.
First Group Lake View Cabanas
African SoivenirsSt Lucia Palms
Hipo's ViewPerna Perna Lodge St Lucia
African SoivenirsElephant Lake Hotel
African Soivenirs