Our pick
English
Stone Mill Inn vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.9Rooms were described as amazing, comfortable, and beautifully restored.
Cleanliness
9.4Rooms were clean and well-maintained.
Location
9.4Conveniently close to downtown and local attractions, though proximity to a run-down area was noted.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
St. Catharines, CA
★ 3-star8/10147 reviews
5.5 km (3.4 mi) from original
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
St. Catharines, CA
★ 3-star8.9/10837 reviews
5.6 km (3.5 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Rodman Hall9.9
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG7.8
Cleanliness
Rodman Hall9.4
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG6.8
Location
Rodman Hall9.4
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG8.3
Service
Rodman Hall9.9
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara9.3
Food & Breakfast
Stone Mill Inn9.3
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG7.8
Amenities & Facilities
Stone Mill Inn9.3
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG8.3
Value
Rodman Hall9.4
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG7.3
Rodman Hall amenity advantages
Accessible shuttle
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG amenity advantages
Concierge serviceBreakfast available (surcharge)
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara amenity advantages
WiFi availableNon-smoking roomsAir conditioningLift / ElevatorLaundry
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.6 km.
Rodman Hall: 3.0 km (1.9 mi)
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara: 5.6 km (3.5 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Stone Mill Inn
9.4/10Rodman Hall
9.4/10Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
8/10Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.9/10Rooms
Stone Mill Inn
9.3Rooms are spacious and well-appointed.
Rodman Hall
9.9Rooms were described as amazing, comfortable, and beautifully restored.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
7.8Nice rooms mentioned, but some issues with old facilities and noise.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.8Rooms were described as comfortable and well-appointed, although a few found beds uncomfortable.
Cleanliness
Stone Mill Inn
9.3Reviews mention the hotel is clean and well-kept.
Rodman Hall
9.4Rooms were clean and well-maintained.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
6.8Reports of dirty floors and unclean bathrooms impacted cleanliness sentiment.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.6Many reviews mention the cleanliness of the hotel as a positive aspect, though there were a few comments about noise and specific cleanliness concerns.
Location
Stone Mill Inn
9.3Conveniently located near attractions and restaurants.
Rodman Hall
9.4Conveniently close to downtown and local attractions, though proximity to a run-down area was noted.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
8.3Location was noted as close to dining options, but some areas felt industrial.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.8Location was generally rated well, but some mentioned it being isolated from attractions.
Service
Stone Mill Inn
9.8Staff is described as friendly and attentive across multiple reviews.
Rodman Hall
9.9Although there was no onsite staff, guests felt warmly welcomed.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
9.3Multiple mentions of friendly and amazing staff.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
9.3Consistent praise for the friendly staff and excellent service across multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
Stone Mill Inn
—Rodman Hall
—Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
—Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
—Food & Breakfast
Stone Mill Inn
9.3Italian restaurant and other dining options praised.
Rodman Hall
8.4No dining facilities, but refreshments available.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
7.8Excellent restaurant food reported, but breakfast access was an issue.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
9.1Breakfast received high marks for quality and variety.
Amenities & Facilities
Stone Mill Inn
9.3Includes desirable features like kitchenette and entertainment.
Rodman Hall
8.9Basic amenities available like tea and coffee; some items need attention.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
8.3Pool and entertainment options were appreciated, though lack of breakfast included.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.7Amenities were appreciated, though there were mentions of some expected features not being available.
Value
Stone Mill Inn
9.2Guests feel they are getting great value for their stay.
Rodman Hall
9.4Good value for the historic charm and quality available.
Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
7.3Guests expressed disappointment over the price relative to breakfast and cleanliness.
Hampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
8.7Fairly rated, though a couple of comments suggested it was expensive for what was offered.
Landmarks
Stone Mill Inn
Merritton War MemorialRodman Hall
Oakhill ParkHoliday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Catharines Conference Center by IHG
Torosian ParkHampton Inn St. Catharines Niagara
John Page Park