
Rivendell Guest House
Southampton, GB
3.8 km (2.4 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Southampton, GB
3.8 km (2.4 mi) from original
Rooms
8.8Comfortable bed but issues with bed quality and small room size.
Cleanliness
9.4Generally positive feedback on cleanliness, but some old-fashioned and smelly areas mentioned.
Location
9.9Good location with access to nearby eateries and peace.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Southampton, GB
3.8 km (2.4 mi) from original

The Pilgrim Inn
8.9/10ibis Southampton
7.5/10Rivendell Guest House
9.4/10The Star Hotel
7.1/10The Pilgrim Inn
8.8Rooms were generally described as comfortable, with good amenities.
ibis Southampton
6.4Several reviews noted rooms were small, dated, or had issues.
Rivendell Guest House
8.8Comfortable bed but issues with bed quality and small room size.
The Star Hotel
6.3Some guests noted rooms were clean but mentioned issues like small sizes and outdated decor.
The Pilgrim Inn
8.8The rooms were noted to be clean and well-appointed, contributing positively to the overall impression.
ibis Southampton
7.0Room condition varied; some guests mentioned dirtiness and discomfort.
Rivendell Guest House
9.4Generally positive feedback on cleanliness, but some old-fashioned and smelly areas mentioned.
The Star Hotel
6.3Most reviews mentioned clean rooms, although some areas were described as a little tired.
The Pilgrim Inn
9.3Multiple reviews highlighted the great location of the hotel.
ibis Southampton
9.0Many guests highlighted great location benefits.
Rivendell Guest House
9.9Good location with access to nearby eateries and peace.
The Star Hotel
7.8Multiple reviews praised the convenient location near the port and city center.
The Pilgrim Inn
9.3Staff were described as friendly, accommodating, and polite across multiple reviews.
ibis Southampton
8.9Staff received consistent praise for helpfulness and friendliness.
Rivendell Guest House
10.0Largely positive service experience with mentions of helpful staff.
The Star Hotel
7.8Staff were described as friendly and accommodating, contributing positively to the overall experience.
The Pilgrim Inn
—ibis Southampton
—Rivendell Guest House
—The Star Hotel
—The Pilgrim Inn
8.3Food quality was praised, but there were complaints about portion sizes and high prices.
ibis Southampton
6.0Breakfast was often described as chaotic with limited options.
Rivendell Guest House
8.4No breakfast included and minor complaints about beverage availability.
The Star Hotel
7.3Breakfast received positive reviews, although some found it monotonous over multiple days.
The Pilgrim Inn
8.8Amenities were mentioned positively, though minor maintenance issues were noted.
ibis Southampton
7.5Basic amenities reported, with some lacking supply and quality.
Rivendell Guest House
8.9Amenities were generally satisfactory, though there were some broken items reported.
The Star Hotel
6.8Basic amenities were provided effectively but lacked some expected features (e.g., hair dryer).
The Pilgrim Inn
8.8Most reviews suggest good value for the price, with many emphasizing the reasonable costs.
ibis Southampton
7.4Guests felt it was acceptable for budget stays, though few noted a lack of quality.
Rivendell Guest House
9.8Good value for the price despite mixed feelings on some aspects.
The Star Hotel
7.8Guests generally felt they received good value for their money given the facilities offered.
The Pilgrim Inn
Millbrook Recreation Groundibis Southampton
StargateRivendell Guest House
Rollesbrook GreenwayThe Star Hotel
Hamtun Street Mural