
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
10.0Rooms noted as very comfortable and well-furnished with positive comments.
Cleanliness
10.0The hotel is described as exceptional in cleanliness, with multiple mentions of spotlessness and comfort.
Location
10.0Several reviews note the great location near attractions and the beach.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Cape May, US
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original

Cape May, US
0.90 km (0.56 mi) from original
La Mer Beachfront Resort
9/10ICONA Cape May
10/10Grand Hotel Cape May
8.6/10Montreal Beach Resort
8.9/10La Mer Beachfront Resort
8.4Rooms are renovated but some are dated.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Rooms noted as very comfortable and well-furnished with positive comments.
Grand Hotel Cape May
7.3Concerns about room conditions and temperature control.
Montreal Beach Resort
8.3Mixed reviews, with some complaints about outdated furniture and lack of amenities.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
8.5Room was clean and cozy according to multiple reviews.
ICONA Cape May
10.0The hotel is described as exceptional in cleanliness, with multiple mentions of spotlessness and comfort.
Grand Hotel Cape May
8.3Some mentions of dirt and worn conditions in reviews.
Montreal Beach Resort
7.3Multiple complaints about cleanliness and poor maintenance, including a sofa with a urine smell and lack of adequate toiletries.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
9.5Property is within walking distance to shops and restaurants.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Several reviews note the great location near attractions and the beach.
Grand Hotel Cape May
9.3Multiple reviews highlight great location near attractions.
Montreal Beach Resort
9.8Location is a standout feature, praised for being near the beach and restaurants.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
9.4Staff was friendly and helpful, as mentioned in several reviews.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Staff was consistently praised for being friendly and accommodating across multiple reviews.
Grand Hotel Cape May
9.3Consistently positive feedback on staff kindness and efficiency.
Montreal Beach Resort
10.0Friendly and accommodating staff, though some issues were not addressed promptly.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
—ICONA Cape May
—Grand Hotel Cape May
—Montreal Beach Resort
—La Mer Beachfront Resort
9.0N/A - Not mentioned.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Not mentioned directly, assuming standard quality for this hotel tier.
Grand Hotel Cape May
8.8Positive comments regarding food quality.
Montreal Beach Resort
9.3No review mentions food quality, but noted that breakfast was not taken.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
9.4Rooms have kitchenettes and other amenities that guests appreciated.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Positive mentions of amenities like free shuttle service and room facilities.
Grand Hotel Cape May
8.8Good amenities, such as the pool and restaurant.
Montreal Beach Resort
8.8Overall decent, though guests were disappointed with the lack of bathrobes and inadequate toiletries.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
8.9Although pricing was mentioned, value perception remained positive.
ICONA Cape May
10.0Good sentiment regarding the value for price paid based on overall stay satisfaction.
Grand Hotel Cape May
8.2Mixed views on value due to room conditions affecting experience.
Montreal Beach Resort
8.3Struggles to match advertised 4-star quality. Perceptions are affected by additional charges for items originally thought to be complimentary.
La Mer Beachfront Resort
Cape May Kiwanis Community ParkICONA Cape May
Cape May Kiwanis Community ParkGrand Hotel Cape May
Cape May Kiwanis Community ParkMontreal Beach Resort
Cape May Kiwanis Community Park