Our pick
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
New York, US
★ 5-star9.2/103,677 reviews
0.35 km (0.21 mi) from original
English
The Knickerbocker Hotel vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
8.5Some reviews highlighted the presence of a roach in the room, suggesting room cleanliness could be improved.
Location
10.0Frequent mentions of the perfect midtown location near major attractions.
Service
10.0Consistently praised across multiple reviews for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
New York, US
★ 5-star9.2/103,677 reviews
0.35 km (0.21 mi) from original
New York Marriott Marquis
New York, US
★ 5-star8.3/104,524 reviews
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
New York, US
★ 4-star7/1013,830 reviews
0.59 km (0.37 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Knickerbocker Hotel9.3
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West5.8
Cleanliness
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel8.5
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West6.3
Location
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel10.0
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West8.8
Service
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel10.0
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West8.3
Food & Breakfast
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel9.0
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West6.8
Amenities & Facilities
The Knickerbocker Hotel8.8
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West6.8
Value
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel9.5
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West6.3
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel amenity advantages
Sauna
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9/10The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.2/10New York Marriott Marquis
8.3/10Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
7/10Rooms
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.3Spacious and comfortable rooms, though some were noted to lack natural light.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Rooms are noted as small but very comfortable, with some statements indicating that furniture should be better adapted.
New York Marriott Marquis
8.2Generally good, but lacking some amenities expected from a 5-star hotel.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
5.8Rooms described as small, with some issues reported regarding heating and comfort.
Cleanliness
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.3Notable mentions of cleanliness, but some maintenance issues reported.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Some reviews highlighted the presence of a roach in the room, suggesting room cleanliness could be improved.
New York Marriott Marquis
7.7Cleanliness could be improved as mentioned.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
6.3Some maintenance issues and complaints about room cleanliness.
Location
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.3Great location in the center of Times Square, easy access to transportation.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
10.0Frequent mentions of the perfect midtown location near major attractions.
New York Marriott Marquis
9.2The location was frequently highlighted as a major positive aspect.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
8.8Fantastic location, central and within easy walking distance of Times Square.
Service
The Knickerbocker Hotel
9.8Exceptional service and hospitality from staff, particularly during special occasions.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
10.0Consistently praised across multiple reviews for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
New York Marriott Marquis
8.7General sentiment regarding service was mixed, with some positive feedback.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
8.3Friendly and welcoming staff, with positive notes on check-in experience.
Sleep & Noise
The Knickerbocker Hotel
—The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
—New York Marriott Marquis
—Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
—Food & Breakfast
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.8Positive comments about restaurant food and service.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.0Generally good breakfast mentioned, though can be crowded at peak times.
New York Marriott Marquis
7.7Mixed reviews on food service, with complaints about quality and availability.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
6.8No specific comments on food were made.
Amenities & Facilities
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.8Good amenities, though some guests expressed a desire for improvements.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
8.5Good amenities noted, but some guests found the breakfast area too busy at times.
New York Marriott Marquis
8.2Room amenities were acceptable but could be better, with some missing items.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
6.8Basic amenities available but some described as outdated.
Value
The Knickerbocker Hotel
8.3Hotel is not cheap but offers good value for the quality of stay.
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
9.5Overall good value with breakfast included and helpful staff.
New York Marriott Marquis
8.1Perception of value was generally positive, but some guests expected more for the price.
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
6.3Felt like it didn't justify the 4-star rating due to issues experienced.
Landmarks
The Knickerbocker Hotel
Times Square BallThe Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel
Marsh & McLennan Public SpaceNew York Marriott Marquis
Times SquareDoubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
The Commuters