Hotel Carlton Plaza vs Similar Hotels

Comfortable beds and quality linens reported, good bathroom amenities, but some guests mentioned bad mattresses, thin walls and poor soundproofing.

General satisfaction with room comfort, though some mentioned the size of the rooms could be better.

Rooms are described as comfortable and well-equipped.

Rooms often described as spacious with large bathrooms, but several guests note old/worn furniture, broken items and some uncomfortable beds or weak lighting, producing a mixed but below-excellent score.

Mostly praised (e.g., 'quarto impecável', lençóis e toalhas trocadas diariamente) but isolated reports of hairs in the bathroom/box indicate occasional lapses.

The rooms were noted as clean and well-kept, but issues with cleanliness in some areas and the presence of flies in the afternoon tea were mentioned.

Some reviews highlighted issues with cleanliness such as towel availability.

Generally reported as clean in several reviews ('limpeza ok', 'limpeza ótima'), but there are notable complaints about dirty/old furniture and a few rooms described as poorly maintained, which lowers this score.

Many comments call the location excellent/marvelous and note proximity to commercial establishments and landmarks.

Consistently praised for its excellent location, close to main attractions and easy access.

Multiple reviews praised the hotel's excellent location.

Very frequently highlighted as a major positive: 'excelente localização', near the center, good views and convenient for guests — consistently strong across reviews.

Consistently positive: staff repeatedly described as attentive, friendly and efficient (reception, restaurant maitre highlighted).

Multiple reviews highlight attentive and friendly staff, contributing positively to the overall service experience.

Positive feedback on staff attentiveness and professionalism.

Staff repeatedly praised as excellent, attentive and dedicated (many mentions of helpful/check-in to check-out service). There are isolated reports of rude or inattentive employees, but overall sentiment is strongly positive.

Breakfast frequently called very good/excellent and restaurant/food praised as delicious; some mention limited variation at breakfast.

Breakfast received positive mentions for variety and quality, enhancing guest satisfaction.

Highly praised breakfast options and dining experience.

Breakfast is frequently described as excellent/exceptional. Dinner buffet and some full-board plates receive comments about limited variety or being bland, and suggestions for more/better fruits, but overall F&B is a strong point.

Strong breakfast offering, brinquedoteca and provided toiletries noted; occasional comment about limited breakfast variation.

Parking fees and limited amenities for pets were points of contention, impacting perceived value.

Good amenities, though some noted ongoing construction.

Thermal/heated pool and good kids' recreation are positives; however issues include pool being cold at times, paid and slow parking, small/limited TVs and occasional limited surrounding services — overall mixed.

Repeated complaints about unexpected paid parking (R$40) and its cost lowered perceived value, though room rates otherwise considered reasonable by some guests.

Some guests felt that the hotel provided good value but raised concerns over additional charges like parking.

Solid value, with a special mention of the breakfast quality.

Multiple guests call the price unbeatable or very accessible and explicitly praise the cost/benefit; isolated complaint about parking fee does not outweigh widespread positive comments.