
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.0Numerous complaints about room size, comfort, and cleanliness.
Cleanliness
8.5Multiple mentions of poor housekeeping and maintenance issues affecting the room quality.
Location
9.9The hotel is praised for its excellent location close to amenities and attractions.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Dunedin, NZ
0.41 km (0.25 mi) from original

Motel on Carroll
7.6/10Fable Dunedin
9.2/10Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
8.3/10Hope Street Apartments
8.2/10Motel on Carroll
6.9Several comments indicate that the rooms are comfortable but several guests noted they were dated or had issues.
Fable Dunedin
8.0Numerous complaints about room size, comfort, and cleanliness.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
7.5Rooms were described as cozy, but some issues like room size and outdated amenities were noted.
Hope Street Apartments
8.2Rooms were spacious and comfortable, but some had issues such as small bathrooms.
Motel on Carroll
7.4Many reviews mention the room cleanliness positively, but some guests noted issues with noise that may affect perceived cleanliness.
Fable Dunedin
8.5Multiple mentions of poor housekeeping and maintenance issues affecting the room quality.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
8.1Most reviews highlighted cleanliness positively, though some mentioned older aspects.
Hope Street Apartments
7.7Some reviews noted that cleanliness was lacking, with dust in a few areas and no cleaning during the stay.
Motel on Carroll
8.4Guests generally appreciate the convenient location for exploring the city and proximity to restaurants.
Fable Dunedin
9.9The hotel is praised for its excellent location close to amenities and attractions.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
9.1Many guests appreciated the close proximity to the city center.
Hope Street Apartments
8.7Several reviews highlighted the good location and easy access to restaurants and the city.
Motel on Carroll
8.4Multiple reviews highlight the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff, particularly Brian, contributing positively to the service rating.
Fable Dunedin
10.0Staff are consistently described as friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
9.0Reviewers praised the owner's responsiveness and helpfulness.
Hope Street Apartments
8.7Nicole the host was contactable and prompt, providing good service.
Motel on Carroll
—Fable Dunedin
—Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
—Hope Street Apartments
—Motel on Carroll
6.9Food and beverage options not specifically mentioned; assigned a standard rating as there were no comments related.
Fable Dunedin
8.9Quality of food service satisfactory, though some complaints about offerings.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
8.4Food and beverage satisfaction was not explicitly mentioned in reviews.
Hope Street Apartments
8.3Not explicitly mentioned in reviews.
Motel on Carroll
6.9Amenities mentioned include good facilities and free laundry; however, some guests noted limited offerings.
Fable Dunedin
8.9Basic amenities mentioned, but some lacked proper functioning.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
8.1Good amenities overall, with notable gaps like weak water pressure in showers.
Hope Street Apartments
7.7Lacked some amenities like a coffee maker and had issues with TV remote and internet access.
Motel on Carroll
7.9Most guests feel they received good value considering the price, despite some limitations in the property.
Fable Dunedin
9.4Fair value given location and service but hindered by cleanliness and room quality issues.
Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
8.0Value was generally viewed positively, though some specific cons were mentioned.
Hope Street Apartments
8.2The overall sentiment was that the hotel offered good value for money.
Motel on Carroll
No 13 Street Art TrailFable Dunedin
No 15 (viewed from inside Van Guard Cafe)Upstairs Apartment in Dunedin Central
Market ReserveHope Street Apartments
No 18