New Design St.Peter vs Similar Hotels

Notable negatives: bathroom tends to collect water (partial wet/dry separation), no mirror in bathroom for shaving, and noisy portable air conditioning. These issues reduce room-quality score.

Comfortable beds and quiet rooms noted, but several mentions of small rooms/bathrooms, missing wardrobe/ hooks and some awkward furnishings.

Rooms vary greatly, with some being very small and others satisfactory.

Rooms are comfortable though some mention issues with noise and mattress quality.

Multiple reviews explicitly note the room and spaces are very clean ("Clean", "la chambre très propre"); overall cleanliness is consistently praised.

Generally reported as clean (daily cleaning, fresh towels), but isolated issues: bathroom seal mold and one report of bad smell.

Multiple reviews indicate a need for improvement in brightness and maintenance.

Generally clean with some mentions of issues with the sofa bed and restaurant service.

Location repeatedly praised as very convenient and ideal ("位置很方便", "proche du métro et du Vatican"); excellent neighbourhood and access to transport/services.

Multiple mentions of excellent central location close to Vatican, metro/bus and restaurants; ideal for sightseeing.

Very convenient for exploring the city and getting to shopping areas.

Ideally located near the Vatican and public transport.

Mixed mentions: one guest found the property impersonal and saw no on-site staff (contact via WhatsApp), but several reviews praise staff as tremendously helpful and describe courtesy and availability ("Cortesia, disponibilità ed accoglienza"). Responsiveness via WhatsApp and helpful interactions justify a high practical service score.

Staff repeatedly described as cordial, welcoming and helpful; staff promptly resolved a toilet issue.

Generally positive, with specific mention of helpful staff at reception.

Staff is very courteous and attentive, providing excellent service throughout the stay.

Limited mentions but the complimentary self-service coffee is appreciated (positive note); no negative comments about F&B were given.

Breakfast generally described as good or excellent with variety (eggs); suggestions for more savory options like fresh cheese and vegetables.

Breakfast variety criticized, but still seen as decent.

Food quality was often mentioned positively, but service in the restaurant was chaotic.

Amenities mentioned include air conditioning and complimentary self-service coffee; despite AC noise reported by one guest, available amenities (coffee, AC, handy facilities) are appreciated.

Good amenities cited: working air conditioning, rooftop terrace with great view, quiet fridge in room; some missing towel hooks and small bathroom bin.

Breakfast received mixed reviews; some amenities were missing.

Nice amenities found in the hotel but some guests want more features like kettles.

Concerns about additional costs lower perceived value: luggage storage fees (22 euros) and a relatively high tourist tax (72 euros for 3 people over 4 nights) were explicitly called out.

Mixed impressions: some found overall service better than 3-star, others felt price was a bit high for room type and breakfast offered.

Fairly priced for the location and amenities, though not the cheapest.

Fair value considering locality and service provided.