Our pick
Waterton Park Hotel
Wakefield, GB
★ 4-star8.2/102,081 reviews
3.6 km (2.3 mi) from original
English
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.0Some rooms are dated and mentioned issues with comfort and amenities.
Location
9.5Lovely location with great views noted in multiple reviews.
Service
9.0Staff were friendly and helpful, consistent positive feedback about the service.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
Wakefield, GB
★ 3-star7.6/101,643 reviews
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
Wakefield, GB
★ 3-star7.5/102,362 reviews
3.4 km (2.1 mi) from original
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Waterton Park Hotel8.0
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western7.2
Cleanliness
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection7.9
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western6.2
Location
Waterton Park Hotel9.5
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western8.2
Service
York House Hotel9.3
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection6.9
Food & Breakfast
Waterton Park Hotel8.0
York House Hotel6.3
Amenities & Facilities
York House Hotel8.3
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection6.9
Value
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection8.3
Waterton Park Hotel7.5
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western amenity advantages
Luggage storage
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
Waterton Park Hotel amenity advantages
Fitness centerSwimming poolRoom serviceSaunaHot tub/Jacuzzi
York House Hotel amenity advantages
Lift / Elevator
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.9 km.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection: 3.4 km (2.1 mi)
York House Hotel: 5.3 km (3.3 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
7.6/10The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
7.5/10Waterton Park Hotel
8.2/10York House Hotel
8/10Rooms
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
7.2Some reports of dated rooms and mixed comfort levels.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
7.3Some rooms are small and dated but generally clean and comfortable.
Waterton Park Hotel
8.0Some rooms are dated and mentioned issues with comfort and amenities.
York House Hotel
7.3Mixed reviews regarding room size and comfort, with mention of dated decor and uncomfortable beds.
Cleanliness
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
6.2Room not very clean and some reports of issues regarding cleanliness.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
7.9The room was exceptionally clean and spotless, with no mould found.
Waterton Park Hotel
7.0Numerous comments about unclean rooms and unexpected findings indicate cleanliness is an issue.
York House Hotel
7.3Concerns about cleanliness from reviews mentioning damp smells, unclean carpets, and flea bites.
Location
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
8.2Convenient access to local attractions and nice surroundings.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
8.4Ideal location 5 mins off the M1, noted positively by multiple reviewers.
Waterton Park Hotel
9.5Lovely location with great views noted in multiple reviews.
York House Hotel
9.3Multiple mentions of the great location near central attractions and transport.
Service
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
9.2Reviews highlighted friendly staff and good service.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
6.9Some staff members were friendly, but others showed confusion and lack of engagement.
Waterton Park Hotel
9.0Staff were friendly and helpful, consistent positive feedback about the service.
York House Hotel
9.3Staff received positive feedback for being friendly and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
—The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
—Waterton Park Hotel
—York House Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
6.7Complaints about food quality and breakfast timings noted in reviews.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
6.9Dinner availability issues noted; some positive mentions of breakfast.
Waterton Park Hotel
8.0Breakfast options were noted as limited, but some meals were enjoyed.
York House Hotel
6.3No breakfast available and dissatisfaction expressed regarding lack of food options.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
7.7Basic amenities with some complaints about specifics like bathroom size and heating.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
6.9Basic amenities provided; suggestions for improvement included adding fridges and better heating.
Waterton Park Hotel
7.5Amenities have been criticized for additional charges and lack of facilities.
York House Hotel
8.3Positive notes on available amenities, though lacking in food options.
Value
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
7.7Some reviews felt the stay was decent for the price but mentioned feeling basic.
The Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
8.3Balance of price and services offered is mainly viewed as good value.
Waterton Park Hotel
7.5Many reviews suggest the rooms did not meet expectations for the price paid.
York House Hotel
8.3Generally considered good value but some facilities were lacking.
Landmarks
Hotel St Pierre, Sure Hotel Collection by Best Western
War MemorialThe Kiln Hotel, Wakefield West Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
Holmfield ParkWaterton Park Hotel
Charles Watertons GraveYork House Hotel
Wakefield Cenotaph