Monastery Hotel vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

JAG Boutique Hotel

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.9/101,811 reviews

0.70 km (0.44 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

8.9

Generally comfortable rooms, though some issues mentioned with room assignments.

Cleanliness

8.5

A couple of mentions of concerns with cleanliness and maintenance.

Location

9.5

Convenient downtown location with access to restaurants and bars.

Close alternatives

Very close alternative

Leaside Manor

Better if you care more about Food & Breakfast.

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Monastery Hotel

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.1/10862 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

JAG Boutique Hotel

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.9/101,811 reviews

0.70 km (0.44 mi) from original

View hotel

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.6/10695 reviews

0.67 km (0.41 mi) from original

View hotel

Leaside Manor

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.9/10658 reviews

0.94 km (0.59 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Leaside Manor

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Food & Breakfast9.2

Key differences

Rooms

JAG Boutique Hotel8.9

Monastery Hotel7.6

Cleanliness

Leaside Manor8.7

Monastery Hotel7.7

Location

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre9.6

Monastery Hotel8.7

Service

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre9.5

Monastery Hotel8.7

Food & Breakfast

Leaside Manor9.2

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre7.6

Amenities & Facilities

JAG Boutique Hotel9.0

Monastery Hotel8.2

Value

Leaside Manor8.7

Monastery Hotel7.6

JAG Boutique Hotel amenity advantages

Concierge serviceFamily rooms

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre amenity advantages

Swimming poolWheelchair accessiblePets allowed

Detailed comparison

Category	Monastery Hotel	JAG Boutique Hotel	Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre	Leaside Manor
Guest score	8.1/10	8.9/10	8.6/10	8.9/10
Rooms	7.6 Some rooms reported issues like noisy surroundings and outdated facilities.	8.9 Generally comfortable rooms, though some issues mentioned with room assignments.	8.0 Some rooms were reported as outdated with issues like old carpets and noisy air conditioning.	8.7 Positive sentiment regarding the spacious and cozy rooms.
Cleanliness	7.7 Multiple reviews mentioned sticky floors and general cleanliness issues.	8.5 A couple of mentions of concerns with cleanliness and maintenance.	8.1 Some reviews indicated areas were untidy and needed improvement, such as the corridors.	8.7 Most reviews mention cleanliness positively, with remarks about the well-maintained and tidy rooms.
Location	8.7 Described as a quiet and convenient location, close to downtown.	9.5 Convenient downtown location with access to restaurants and bars.	9.6 The hotel is conveniently located near a concert venue, making it highly rated for location.	8.8 The hotel's location is appreciated for its convenience to downtown and surrounding areas.
Service	8.7 Overall friendly staff, but some reviews indicated service issues during check-in.	9.4 Positive mentions of helpful and friendly staff.	9.5 Multiple reviewers praised the staff for their friendliness and helpfulness.	9.2 Numerous reviews highlight the friendliness and helpful nature of the staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.2 No specific negative reviews regarding food, but some missing amenities.	8.0 Mixed reviews on food quality; improvements needed.	7.6 Reviews indicated dissatisfaction with the breakfast at the restaurant.	9.2 Breakfast receives high praise, particularly for variety and quality.
Amenities & Facilities	8.2 Facilities like jacuzzi mentioned positively, despite some technical issues.	9.0 Amenities are appreciated, though some limitations noted with pool hours.	8.6 Amenities like the pool and gym were mentioned positively, though some areas need refreshment.	8.7 Amenities are generally noted positively, especially the breakfast options.
Value	7.6 Critiques on pricing in relation to the given services and amenities.	8.4 Some reviews mentioned high prices for quality; reflects mixed sentiments.	8.5 Feedback suggests that for the price, some felt the room quality did not meet expectations.	8.7 Many guests perceived the hotel to offer good value for the price.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.70 km (0.44 mi)	0.67 km (0.41 mi)	0.94 km (0.59 mi)
Landmarks	Victoria Park	Chinese Head Tax Monument	Compass Rose	Brother Eagan Park
Best suited for	Business travelers	Solo travelers	Comfort-focused travelers	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Monastery Hotel

8.1/10

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.9/10

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.6/10

Leaside Manor

8.9/10

Rooms

Monastery Hotel

7.6

Some rooms reported issues like noisy surroundings and outdated facilities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.9

Generally comfortable rooms, though some issues mentioned with room assignments.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.0

Some rooms were reported as outdated with issues like old carpets and noisy air conditioning.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Positive sentiment regarding the spacious and cozy rooms.

Cleanliness

Monastery Hotel

7.7

Multiple reviews mentioned sticky floors and general cleanliness issues.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.5

A couple of mentions of concerns with cleanliness and maintenance.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.1

Some reviews indicated areas were untidy and needed improvement, such as the corridors.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Most reviews mention cleanliness positively, with remarks about the well-maintained and tidy rooms.

Location

Monastery Hotel

8.7

Described as a quiet and convenient location, close to downtown.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.5

Convenient downtown location with access to restaurants and bars.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

9.6

The hotel is conveniently located near a concert venue, making it highly rated for location.

Leaside Manor

8.8

The hotel's location is appreciated for its convenience to downtown and surrounding areas.

Service

Monastery Hotel

8.7

Overall friendly staff, but some reviews indicated service issues during check-in.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.4

Positive mentions of helpful and friendly staff.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

9.5

Multiple reviewers praised the staff for their friendliness and helpfulness.

Leaside Manor

9.2

Numerous reviews highlight the friendliness and helpful nature of the staff.

Sleep & Noise

Monastery Hotel

—

JAG Boutique Hotel

—

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

—

Leaside Manor

—

Food & Breakfast

Monastery Hotel

8.2

No specific negative reviews regarding food, but some missing amenities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.0

Mixed reviews on food quality; improvements needed.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

7.6

Reviews indicated dissatisfaction with the breakfast at the restaurant.

Leaside Manor

9.2

Breakfast receives high praise, particularly for variety and quality.

Amenities & Facilities

Monastery Hotel

8.2

Facilities like jacuzzi mentioned positively, despite some technical issues.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.0

Amenities are appreciated, though some limitations noted with pool hours.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.6

Amenities like the pool and gym were mentioned positively, though some areas need refreshment.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Amenities are generally noted positively, especially the breakfast options.

Value

Monastery Hotel

7.6

Critiques on pricing in relation to the given services and amenities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.4

Some reviews mentioned high prices for quality; reflects mixed sentiments.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.5

Feedback suggests that for the price, some felt the room quality did not meet expectations.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Many guests perceived the hotel to offer good value for the price.

Landmarks

Monastery Hotel

Victoria Park

JAG Boutique Hotel

Chinese Head Tax Monument

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

Compass Rose

Leaside Manor

Brother Eagan Park

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Monastery Hotel

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.1/10862 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

JAG Boutique Hotel

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.9/101,811 reviews

0.70 km (0.44 mi) from original

View hotel

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.6/10695 reviews

0.67 km (0.41 mi) from original

View hotel

Leaside Manor

St. John's, CA

★ 4-star8.9/10658 reviews

0.94 km (0.59 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Monastery Hotel	JAG Boutique Hotel	Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre	Leaside Manor
Guest score	8.1/10	8.9/10	8.6/10	8.9/10
Rooms	7.6 Some rooms reported issues like noisy surroundings and outdated facilities.	8.9 Generally comfortable rooms, though some issues mentioned with room assignments.	8.0 Some rooms were reported as outdated with issues like old carpets and noisy air conditioning.	8.7 Positive sentiment regarding the spacious and cozy rooms.
Cleanliness	7.7 Multiple reviews mentioned sticky floors and general cleanliness issues.	8.5 A couple of mentions of concerns with cleanliness and maintenance.	8.1 Some reviews indicated areas were untidy and needed improvement, such as the corridors.	8.7 Most reviews mention cleanliness positively, with remarks about the well-maintained and tidy rooms.
Location	8.7 Described as a quiet and convenient location, close to downtown.	9.5 Convenient downtown location with access to restaurants and bars.	9.6 The hotel is conveniently located near a concert venue, making it highly rated for location.	8.8 The hotel's location is appreciated for its convenience to downtown and surrounding areas.
Service	8.7 Overall friendly staff, but some reviews indicated service issues during check-in.	9.4 Positive mentions of helpful and friendly staff.	9.5 Multiple reviewers praised the staff for their friendliness and helpfulness.	9.2 Numerous reviews highlight the friendliness and helpful nature of the staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.2 No specific negative reviews regarding food, but some missing amenities.	8.0 Mixed reviews on food quality; improvements needed.	7.6 Reviews indicated dissatisfaction with the breakfast at the restaurant.	9.2 Breakfast receives high praise, particularly for variety and quality.
Amenities & Facilities	8.2 Facilities like jacuzzi mentioned positively, despite some technical issues.	9.0 Amenities are appreciated, though some limitations noted with pool hours.	8.6 Amenities like the pool and gym were mentioned positively, though some areas need refreshment.	8.7 Amenities are generally noted positively, especially the breakfast options.
Value	7.6 Critiques on pricing in relation to the given services and amenities.	8.4 Some reviews mentioned high prices for quality; reflects mixed sentiments.	8.5 Feedback suggests that for the price, some felt the room quality did not meet expectations.	8.7 Many guests perceived the hotel to offer good value for the price.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.70 km (0.44 mi)	0.67 km (0.41 mi)	0.94 km (0.59 mi)
Landmarks	Victoria Park	Chinese Head Tax Monument	Compass Rose	Brother Eagan Park
Best suited for	Business travelers	Solo travelers	Comfort-focused travelers	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Monastery Hotel

8.1/10

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.9/10

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.6/10

Leaside Manor

8.9/10

Rooms

Monastery Hotel

7.6

Some rooms reported issues like noisy surroundings and outdated facilities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.9

Generally comfortable rooms, though some issues mentioned with room assignments.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.0

Some rooms were reported as outdated with issues like old carpets and noisy air conditioning.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Positive sentiment regarding the spacious and cozy rooms.

Cleanliness

Monastery Hotel

7.7

Multiple reviews mentioned sticky floors and general cleanliness issues.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.5

A couple of mentions of concerns with cleanliness and maintenance.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.1

Some reviews indicated areas were untidy and needed improvement, such as the corridors.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Most reviews mention cleanliness positively, with remarks about the well-maintained and tidy rooms.

Location

Monastery Hotel

8.7

Described as a quiet and convenient location, close to downtown.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.5

Convenient downtown location with access to restaurants and bars.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

9.6

The hotel is conveniently located near a concert venue, making it highly rated for location.

Leaside Manor

8.8

The hotel's location is appreciated for its convenience to downtown and surrounding areas.

Service

Monastery Hotel

8.7

Overall friendly staff, but some reviews indicated service issues during check-in.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.4

Positive mentions of helpful and friendly staff.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

9.5

Multiple reviewers praised the staff for their friendliness and helpfulness.

Leaside Manor

9.2

Numerous reviews highlight the friendliness and helpful nature of the staff.

Sleep & Noise

Monastery Hotel

—

JAG Boutique Hotel

—

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

—

Leaside Manor

—

Food & Breakfast

Monastery Hotel

8.2

No specific negative reviews regarding food, but some missing amenities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.0

Mixed reviews on food quality; improvements needed.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

7.6

Reviews indicated dissatisfaction with the breakfast at the restaurant.

Leaside Manor

9.2

Breakfast receives high praise, particularly for variety and quality.

Amenities & Facilities

Monastery Hotel

8.2

Facilities like jacuzzi mentioned positively, despite some technical issues.

JAG Boutique Hotel

9.0

Amenities are appreciated, though some limitations noted with pool hours.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.6

Amenities like the pool and gym were mentioned positively, though some areas need refreshment.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Amenities are generally noted positively, especially the breakfast options.

Value

Monastery Hotel

7.6

Critiques on pricing in relation to the given services and amenities.

JAG Boutique Hotel

8.4

Some reviews mentioned high prices for quality; reflects mixed sentiments.

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

8.5

Feedback suggests that for the price, some felt the room quality did not meet expectations.

Leaside Manor

8.7

Many guests perceived the hotel to offer good value for the price.

Landmarks

Monastery Hotel

Victoria Park

JAG Boutique Hotel

Chinese Head Tax Monument

Delta Hotels by Marriott St. John's Conference Centre

Compass Rose

Leaside Manor

Brother Eagan Park