
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Rooms are generally described as comfortable, but there were some issues with a small and dated room.
Cleanliness
8.4Some reviews mention specifics like cleanliness but also mention minor issues such as mould on bathroom blind.
Location
9.4Multiple reviews highlight the excellent location near the town centre.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Royal Oak at Keswick
8.7/10Inn on the Square
8.7/10The Edwardene
9.1/10Skiddaw Hotel
8.8/10Royal Oak at Keswick
8.6Rooms are generally described as comfortable and spacious, though some reviewers noted issues with certain rooms being small or lacking natural light.
Inn on the Square
8.6Rooms were noted to be modern and well-prepared; however, some guests remarked on noise issues.
The Edwardene
8.8Rooms are generally described as comfortable, but there were some issues with a small and dated room.
Skiddaw Hotel
8.3Rooms were described as comfortable, but some issues with size and condition were noted.
Royal Oak at Keswick
8.3The reviews indicate a generally clean environment, though some reviewers reported minor cleanliness issues related to room amenities.
Inn on the Square
8.2Most guests noted the hotel was clean; however, there were mentions of issues such as breakfast quality and parking fees that affected perceptions.
The Edwardene
8.4Some reviews mention specifics like cleanliness but also mention minor issues such as mould on bathroom blind.
Skiddaw Hotel
7.9Issues with mould in some rooms and damp patches were noted.
Royal Oak at Keswick
9.1The hotel is praised for its ideal location in the center of town, making it convenient for guests.
Inn on the Square
9.2The central location and proximity to attractions were repeatedly praised by guests.
The Edwardene
9.4Multiple reviews highlight the excellent location near the town centre.
Skiddaw Hotel
9.4Location was consistently praised as outstanding and convenient.
Royal Oak at Keswick
9.1Multiple reviews highlight excellent and attentive service from staff, enhancing the overall experience.
Inn on the Square
9.2The staff were frequently highlighted as wonderful and helpful, contributing to a positive service experience.
The Edwardene
9.6Consistently praised as friendly and accommodating across multiple reviews.
Skiddaw Hotel
9.3Staff were described as helpful, professional, and friendly.
Royal Oak at Keswick
—Inn on the Square
—The Edwardene
—Skiddaw Hotel
—Royal Oak at Keswick
8.4Dining experiences were mostly positive, with good breakfasts reported but some dissatisfaction with specific dinner dishes.
Inn on the Square
8.7Most reviews praised the breakfast and restaurant offerings, although there were some criticisms of cost.
The Edwardene
9.6Breakfast has been highlighted as excellent with a variety of choices.
Skiddaw Hotel
8.9Breakfast and food quality were praised, contributing positively.
Royal Oak at Keswick
8.6Amenities received mixed feedback, but positive mentions about complimentary items and good breakfast offerings prevailing.
Inn on the Square
8.7Amenities were generally appreciated, but the added cost for parking detracted from the experience.
The Edwardene
8.9Amenities such as the lounge and honesty bar were mentioned positively.
Skiddaw Hotel
8.9No major complaints, but minor issues with amenities like the Hifi.
Royal Oak at Keswick
8.6The perceived value aligns with the level of service and quality, though some room sizes raised concerns.
Inn on the Square
8.1Guests expressed some doubt about the value for money, particularly relating to parking and breakfast pricing.
The Edwardene
8.8Good value for the location and overall experience, despite some negative feedback.
Skiddaw Hotel
8.3Parking costs were noted as expensive, affecting perceived value.
Royal Oak at Keswick
The Moot HallInn on the Square
The Moot HallThe Edwardene
Keswick War MemorialSkiddaw Hotel
The Moot Hall