
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.2Rooms were often described as comfortable, well-furnished, and spacious.
Cleanliness
9.3Mostly mentioned as clean and well-presented in multiple reviews.
Location
9.3Many reviews praised the location's convenience and scenic aspects.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.



Guildford, GB
4.9 km (3.0 mi) from original

Guildford, GB
4.5 km (2.8 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.0 km.
The Percy Arms: 1.9 km (1.2 mi)
Mandolay Hotel Guildford: 4.9 km (3.0 mi)
Barnett Hill Hotel
8.2/10The Percy Arms
9.2/10Mandolay Hotel Guildford
8.8/10Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
7.7/10Barnett Hill Hotel
7.4Issues with room upkeep and uncomfortable conditions noted.
The Percy Arms
9.2Rooms were often described as comfortable, well-furnished, and spacious.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
8.2Rooms are noted to be clean and comfortable; however, some guests were disappointed by room size and noise.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
6.8Rooms were mentioned as needing care and having issues with heating and cleanliness.
Barnett Hill Hotel
7.4Damp and dirty carpeting noted; bugs in the bathroom.
The Percy Arms
9.3Mostly mentioned as clean and well-presented in multiple reviews.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
8.3General sentiment of cleanliness was mentioned positively in several reviews but noted some noise disruptions.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
5.8Multiple reviews highlighted dirty conditions and poor maintenance.
Barnett Hill Hotel
9.4Beautiful old building in a lovely setting.
The Percy Arms
9.3Many reviews praised the location's convenience and scenic aspects.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
9.3The hotel is frequently praised for its excellent location.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
9.3The location was frequently praised in several reviews.
Barnett Hill Hotel
9.4Staff were very pleasant and helpful.
The Percy Arms
9.7Staff were consistently described as friendly, helpful, and attentive.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
9.3Staff were described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
8.8Staff were noted to be helpful, although service could be improved during breakfast.
Barnett Hill Hotel
—The Percy Arms
—Mandolay Hotel Guildford
—Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
—Barnett Hill Hotel
8.4Breakfast was amazing, but kitchen closed for dinner during Christmas.
The Percy Arms
9.3Food quality received high praise, though pricing was a concern for some.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
9.3Breakfast received high praise for its variety and quality.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
5.8Food quality was mentioned negatively in multiple reviews.
Barnett Hill Hotel
7.9Basic TV channel options and lack of tea/coffee provisions in the room.
The Percy Arms
8.8Amenities were mentioned positively but with some room for improvement.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
8.8Amenities such as bar, restaurant, and Nespresso in the room received positive feedback but some found them inadequate.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
8.3Spa and certain facilities were well-received despite some complaints.
Barnett Hill Hotel
7.4Felt £50 for early check-in was unreasonable.
The Percy Arms
8.7Food was noted as slightly pricey, impacting perceived value.
Mandolay Hotel Guildford
8.2Some reviews indicated it was overpriced for the experience provided.
Guildford Manor Hotel & Spa
8.3Some found the price reasonable considering the facilities, while others disagreed.
Barnett Hill Hotel
Wonersh HouseThe Percy Arms
Expense MagazineMandolay Hotel Guildford
JunoGuildford Manor Hotel & Spa
Surrey Hills Boundary Sculpture