Astor House vs Similar Hotels

Some comments on comfort, but discomfort in bed and lack of functionality in some areas mentioned.

Rooms are described as lovely, clean, and spacious.

Mixed reports: some rooms spacious and exceptional, others basic, dated or with small ensuites; significant noise issues from above rooms and pub/functions reduced perceived room quality.

Many guests found the rooms comfortable, despite some issues mentioned.

Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness, including unclean plates and a smelly fridge.

Reviews frequently mention the hotel being very clean and well-kept.

Rooms and bathrooms repeatedly described as clean; some guests noted small/dated ensuites and a musty/basic room in one report, but overall cleanliness is good.

Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, such as crumbs and bathroom conditions.

Numerous comments highlight the excellent location with stunning views.

The hotel is praised for its brilliant location near the seafront.

Excellent seafront position and views, short walk to theatre/shops/transport; location is frequently praised as a key benefit.

Good comments regarding location and access to town and harbour.

No specific issues mentioned with service; perceived as accommodating.

Many reviews praise the friendly and helpful staff.

Staff repeatedly called friendly, helpful and accommodating (reception, booking adjustments, assistance), cited as a strong point across many reviews.

Multiple reviews highlighted the warm welcome and effort by the hosts.

Not mentioned specifically in reviews; standard quality for this hotel tier.

Breakfast is frequently highlighted as exceptional and well-cooked.

Breakfast is frequently praised (cooked-to-order hot options, full English, gluten-free available) and pub food generally positive, though some guests experienced waits for refills or limited breakfast availability.

Breakfast was well-liked, but some found certain items lacking in quality.

Amenities such as kitchen and TV were well noted, but some issues like steps could be a downside.

Guests appreciate the honesty bar and key fob for access.

Amenities include a pool, terrace/outside space and free parking; bar/restaurant available but hotel functions and limited breakfast service/order procedures were occasionally inconvenient.

General amenities were available, but some lacked particular comforts.

Mixed feelings due to some complaints about the state of the property, leading to a lower assessment.

Overall value perceived as very good considering the quality and service.

Multiple guests described the hotel as very good value, praising pricing relative to the experience and service received.

Some reviews reported costs as high for certain items but overall considered good value.