Our pick
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
Doncaster, GB
★ 4-star9/10156 reviews
0.86 km (0.53 mi) from original
English
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Location
9.4Location described as excellent and convenient.
Service
9.9Staff are frequently praised for friendliness and helpfulness.
Value
8.8Value noted with reasonable prices for the stay.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
Doncaster, GB
★ 3-star7.6/102,123 reviews
1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original
Our pick
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
Doncaster, GB
★ 4-star9/10156 reviews
0.86 km (0.53 mi) from original
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
Doncaster, GB
★ 0-star7/102,244 reviews
0.89 km (0.56 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse9.3
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection5.6
Cleanliness
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse9.3
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection5.6
Location
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel9.4
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection8.2
Service
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel9.9
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection8.1
Food & Breakfast
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse9.3
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel7.4
Amenities & Facilities
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel8.9
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection6.1
Value
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel8.8
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel6.8
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse amenity advantages
Fitness centerRoom serviceLaundryWheelchair accessiblePets allowed
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel amenity advantages
Breakfast in the room
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel amenity advantages
Conference space
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.91 km.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel: 0.86 km (0.53 mi)
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel: 1.8 km (1.1 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9/10Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
7.6/10The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
9/10The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
7/10Rooms
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9.3Rooms are mentioned as comfortable and spacious, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
6.8Mixed reviews about room quality, with some mentioning maintenance issues.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
8.3Rooms mentioned as a bit tired and needing maintenance.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
5.6Dated rooms and reports of uncomfortable beds.
Cleanliness
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9.3The reviews frequently mention clean rooms and tidy facilities, reflecting a high standard of cleanliness.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
7.9Many reviews highlight the overall cleanliness of the hotel.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
8.4Some concerns about cleanliness due to unwashed glasses and maintenance needed.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
5.6Reports of dirty bedding and unclean conditions in some rooms.
Location
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9.3The location is often praised, particularly in relation to its accessibility.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
8.9The hotel is in a great location, close to shops and bars.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
9.4Location described as excellent and convenient.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
8.2Convenient location close to shops and entertainment areas.
Service
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9.3Staff are frequently described as attentive, friendly, and accommodating, providing excellent service.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
8.3The staff received positive feedback for their friendliness and helpfulness.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
9.9Staff are frequently praised for friendliness and helpfulness.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
8.1Staff are exceptional and welcoming according to several reviews.
Sleep & Noise
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
—Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
—The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
—The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
—Food & Breakfast
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
9.3The restaurant is noted for its quality meals and service, making it a highlight for many guests.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
7.4Breakfast options were generally appreciated, though some suggestions for improvement noted.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
8.9Food is generally good, though some found it pricy.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
8.1Excellent cooked breakfast mentioned positively in reviews.
Amenities & Facilities
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
8.3Amenities are generally sufficient, but some reviews hint at additional charges that could deter guests.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
7.3Basic amenities are provided, but some improvements are needed.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
8.9Amenities are decent, minor improvements suggested.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
6.1Basic amenities mentioned, with some concerns about parking fees.
Value
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
8.3While the hotel provides a good experience, parking fees can detract from the overall value.
Mercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
6.8Guests felt that the current state of the hotel does not match its pricing.
The Earl of Doncaster Hotel
8.8Value noted with reasonable prices for the stay.
The Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
7.6Good value for the price despite some negatives.
Landmarks
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse
Runway ParkMercure Doncaster Centre Danum Hotel
DanumThe Earl of Doncaster Hotel
Elmfield ParkThe Raceby Hotel, Doncaster South Yorkshire, Part of the AG Collection
Runway Park